Streamlining Truth-in-Pricing requirements and repealing section 20-708.1 of such code, relating to item pricing

Summary#

Introduction 1028-2026, sponsored by Council Member Harvey D. Epstein, would amend the New York City Administrative Code and repeal its item-pricing section. Its stated goal is to streamline Truth-in-Pricing requirements. The bill is waiting in committee and is not law; if enacted, it would take effect 180 days after becoming law.

  • Sellers would have to display the total selling price, before tax, for consumer commodities at the point where they are offered or displayed for sale. They could use a tag on the item or a sign that identifies the item. The rule would not apply to items displayed in a seller’s window.
  • The bill would repeal the separate item-pricing section. The Council’s summary says current law requires item prices on some products and display prices for others; the current text of the Administrative Code was not supplied, so that description could not be checked against the existing law.
  • The Department of Consumer and Worker Protection (DCWP) would be permitted to inspect a seller’s computer-assisted price scanner, comparing prices for up to 500 items in one inspection. Sellers would have to provide the access needed for the inspection.
  • A seller could not charge more than the lowest applicable tag, label, sign, sale, or advertised price. The bill would also set civil penalties and allow a first-violation penalty of zero dollars if the seller proves it corrected the violation within 30 days, before an adjudication begins. Accepted proof counts as an admission of liability.

What it means for you#

  • Retail sellers: The display rule would apply to consumer commodities, a defined category that excludes drugs and cosmetics. A seller could use an item tag or an identifying sign; the bill would not require an individual tag on every item.
  • Retail sellers using price scanners: DCWP could inspect the scanner, and the seller would have to provide necessary access. Each stock keeping unit (a group of items with the same brand, quantity, price, and variety) in violation on a day would count as a separate violation.
  • Consumers: The bill would prohibit charging more than the lowest applicable displayed or advertised price. It does not create a new consumer benefit or guarantee that every item will have its own tag.
  • Sellers receiving a first notice for a display-price violation: They could seek a zero-dollar civil penalty by proving a cure within the bill’s stated 30-day period. The bill removes the current text’s express 15-day route to seek administrative review of a DCWP decision rejecting proof of a cure.
  • Taxpayers: The bill does not directly change taxes.

Money#

No cost estimate is in the available material.

  • DCWP would have inspection authority; the bill does not estimate the staff or other costs of using it. Sellers would have to provide scanner access when needed.
  • Civil penalties would be capped at $50 for a first violation, $175 for a second, and $250 for a third and each later violation. A qualifying first display-price violation could carry a zero-dollar penalty.
  • The bill removes wording that allows a fine upon conviction, but the supplied materials do not explain how that change would affect enforcement in practice.

What is unclear#

  • The current Administrative Code text was not supplied, so the full difference between existing law and the bill cannot be verified.
  • The bill does not explain how DCWP would choose which items to inspect or how it would carry out inspections.
  • It does not say whether DCWP needs new staff or funding to use the inspection power.
  • The bill does not explain how removing the stated administrative review route for rejected cure proof would interact with other review procedures.

Case for#

  • The Council’s summary says different products currently face different pricing-display rules. A possible argument for the bill is that one display rule could make pricing requirements more consistent.
  • The bill would let sellers use a sign identifying an item instead of attaching a price tag to each item, while retaining a limit on what sellers may charge.
  • The scanner-inspection power could help DCWP check whether programmed prices match the prices sellers disclose.

Case against#

  • One concern is that replacing individual item tags with signs could make prices less apparent when the sign is not easy to match to an item.
  • The bill would require sellers to provide scanner access and could count each non-compliant stock keeping unit on a day as a separate violation. The bill does not estimate the resulting compliance burden.
  • The bill removes the express 15-day administrative review route for a decision rejecting proof of a cure; it does not explain what review, if any, would remain.