Providing an enforcement mechanism against unfair methods of competition, and unfair, deceptive, abusive, or unlawful acts or practices in business, trade, or commerce, and to deter the continuing use of such practices

Summary#

Int. 1105-2026, sponsored by Council Member Harvey D. Epstein, is a proposed local law to amend New York City’s Administrative Code by adding a new chapter on unfair business practices. It would prohibit specified conduct and create ways for injured people and nonprofit organizations to bring court cases; its stated goal is to deter such practices and provide redress. It was introduced and referred to committee on October 8, 2026, and is waiting there; it is not law.

  • The ban would cover unfair methods of competition and unfair, deceptive, abusive, or unlawful acts or practices in or affecting business, trade, or commerce.
  • A person injured by a violation could sue individually, for similarly situated people, or on behalf of the general public. Nonprofit organizations could also bring specified cases, subject to a court’s review of whether they have a sufficient connection to the people they represent.
  • A case could seek compensatory, injunctive, and declaratory relief, including actual damages and $2,500 per violation. A court must award reasonable legal fees and costs to a plaintiff who wins.
  • Before most cases, the claimant must give notice and allow 10 business days for a written response. The bill provides exceptions, including counterclaims and urgent cases.
  • The bill bars a private right of action under this chapter against the city, its agencies or employees, or a “small business” (defined as independently owned and operated, not dominant in its field, with four or fewer employees and under $5 million in revenue in the prior fiscal year). It does not assign enforcement to a city agency.

What it means for you#

  • Consumers, workers, and other people: If you are injured by a covered practice, you could bring a case within three years of when you knew or should have known of the alleged violation. You would not have to show that you relied on the practice. The bill says injury can include non-monetary harm, such as lost time, privacy, or security.
  • Businesses: The ban could expose businesses, other than small businesses as defined, to claims and court-ordered remedies. A complete defense would apply if the challenged conduct is required by specified federal rules or laws as interpreted by the relevant federal authorities or courts.
  • Small businesses: The bill would not create a private right of action against a business meeting its definition of “small business.” The prohibition itself is not limited to large businesses, but the bill does not set out a separate enforcement route for violations by small businesses.
  • Nonprofit organizations: They could bring cases for themselves, members, or injured members of the public, including in some cases involving goods or services bought or received for testing.
  • City agencies and the public: The bill does not create a city agency enforcement process. It would take effect immediately if enacted.

Money#

No public cost estimate is available in the supplied material.

  • The bill includes no appropriation or estimate for city staffing or other public spending.
  • It could result in damages, including $2,500 per violation, and legal fees and costs awarded to a winning plaintiff. The bill does not explain how a court would count violations.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “deceptive” or “unlawful” in this chapter, and does not explain how courts should count violations for the $2,500 amount.
  • It does not set out a city enforcement process or explain how the prohibition would be enforced when a private case cannot be brought, including against a small business.
  • The Council’s findings refer to federal laws and policy statements, but the bill does not explain how conflicts or changes in those materials would affect cases.
  • The Council’s findings describe changes in New York state law, but the state-law text is not supplied here to verify that comparison.

Case for#

  • The Council’s findings say the bill is meant to provide remedies for unfair and abusive practices without relying on federal or state oversight.
  • The Council says the private right of action could deter prohibited conduct and help consumers, workers, and small businesses seek redress.
  • The bill allows cases without proof of reliance and recognizes some non-monetary injuries, which could make it possible to seek a remedy for harms beyond direct financial loss.

Case against#

  • The ban uses broad categories of conduct, while some key terms and how courts should apply them are not fully explained in the bill.
  • A possible trade-off is that damages per violation and mandatory legal-fee awards for winning plaintiffs could create significant exposure for businesses; the bill does not estimate that exposure.
  • The private-case route does not apply against small businesses as defined, and the bill does not set out another enforcement route for them.
  • The bill requires notice before most cases but does not establish a process for resolving disagreements before they reach court.