Definitions and applicability of deceptive and unconscionable trade practices

Summary#

Int. 1168-2026, sponsored by Council Member Chi A. Ossé, would amend New York City’s Administrative Code rules on deceptive and unconscionable trade practices. It aims to expand consumer protections and make enforcement possible without first declaring an act unconscionable in a local law or a Department of Consumer and Worker Protection (DCWP) rule. It has only been introduced and referred to a committee; it is not law.

  • The bill would broaden the definition of a deceptive trade practice to cover misleading statements or omissions made in business, even if they do not name a particular consumer good or service.
  • It would remove the requirement that an act be declared unconscionable before the Commissioner of DCWP can enforce the law. The bill lists six factors for deciding whether a practice is unconscionable, including unfair advantage of a consumer’s limits and a gross gap between price and value.
  • It would allow penalties to be based on each consumer reached by a deceptive or unconscionable statement or omission, if DCWP has evidence of the number reached and that the person responsible knew or should have known the practice was unlawful.
  • The bill would allow the city to seek enforcement in New York State Supreme Court by a special proceeding (a court process). The Commissioner could also bring a notice-of-violation case before a designated city tribunal.

What it means for you#

  • Consumers: The rules would cover consumer goods and services, credit, and debt collection, including transactions mainly for personal, household, or family use. The bill does not create a new complaint or application process for consumers.
  • Businesses and merchants: The definitions could cover a wider range of business statements and omissions. Merchants include sellers, lessors, creditors, manufacturers, wholesalers, and others responsible for prohibited practices.
  • Businesses and DCWP: A statement or omission may count as a separate violation; repeated public exposure in a day may count separately. Under the bill’s evidence conditions, penalties may instead be based on each consumer reached.
  • Pending cases: The Council’s summary says the bill would not affect cases or proceedings already pending when it takes effect. The supplied bill text does not include that provision.

Money#

No cost estimate is provided in the available material.

  • The bill could increase penalties by allowing them to be counted per consumer reached in specified circumstances. It does not state a penalty amount.
  • The bill does not provide a staffing or enforcement budget for DCWP.

What is unclear#

  • The current Administrative Code text is not supplied, so the full extent of changes to existing rules cannot be independently checked. The bill text does show removal of the requirement for a prior declaration of unconscionability.
  • The bill does not explain how DCWP would count consumers reached or prove the number reached.
  • It does not set out a new process, timeline, or appeal route for enforcement.
  • The Council summary describes protection for pending cases, but the supplied bill text does not show how that would be implemented.
  • The committee name is not given in the available history.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that DCWP could act against an unconscionable practice without waiting for a local law or rule to name it first.
  • The listed factors could help assess practices that take unfair advantage of consumers or impose prices far out of line with value.
  • Counting violations by consumers reached, when DCWP has the required evidence, could reflect the reach of a misleading practice.

Case against#

  • Removing the prior-declaration requirement could leave more room for disputes over whether a practice is unconscionable; the bill does not add a decision process or appeal rules.
  • Counting penalties per consumer reached could increase potential penalties, while the bill does not state a dollar amount or explain how reach would be measured.
  • The bill’s definitions cover broad business conduct, including statements that do not name a specific good or service. Businesses may need further guidance on how those terms will be applied.