Zoning power could shift to planning board

Summary#

H-1225, the “Winston-Salem Zoning Procedure Changes” bill, would amend North Carolina’s zoning statute, G.S. 160D-602. Its stated goal is to let the City of Winston-Salem’s planning board hold hearings and make final decisions on zoning amendment requests; the bill’s operative text would let the City’s governing board delegate rezoning authority to that board. The bill is introduced and is not law.

  • The governing board may delegate or assign rezoning authority to a designated planning board by ordinance; it does not have to do so.
  • If it delegates that authority, the governing board must provide a right to appeal and review before itself, under rules it adopts.
  • The planning board must exercise delegated authority under rules, regulations, and guidelines set by the governing board.
  • The bill applies only to Winston-Salem and would take effect when it becomes law.

What it means for you#

  • People seeking or affected by a rezoning: If the City delegates authority, the planning board could decide rezoning matters instead of the governing board at the first stage. The bill does not itself rezone any property or change zoning rules.
  • People appealing a delegated decision: The governing board must provide a right to appeal and review before it. The bill does not set out how that process works.
  • Winston-Salem’s governing board: It may choose whether to delegate rezoning authority. If it does, it must adopt rules and provide for appeal and review.
  • Other North Carolina residents and cities: The bill applies only to Winston-Salem.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill does not state an appropriation or staffing requirement. The cost, if any, of adopting rules or using the delegation is not estimated.

What is unclear#

  • The current text of G.S. 160D-602 was not supplied, so it is not possible to verify what authority Winston-Salem’s planning board or governing board already has, or exactly what would change.
  • The bill does not describe how hearings would work, although its stated title says the planning board could hold them.
  • It does not set the appeal process, deadlines, review standard, or whether an appeal pauses a decision.
  • It does not say what kinds of rezoning requests could be delegated, or how the governing board would decide whether to delegate them.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that the City could assign rezoning decisions to its planning board while keeping a right of appeal and review before the governing board.
  • The governing board would retain control over whether to delegate and could set rules and guidelines for the planning board.

Case against#

  • One concern is that, if the City delegates authority, the planning board could make rezoning decisions without the governing board deciding each request first.
  • The bill leaves important details of hearings and appeals to rules the governing board would adopt, rather than setting them in the bill.
  • Because the current statute was not supplied, it is unclear how much authority this bill would add compared with current law.