Rezoning power may move to joint board

Summary#

H-1226, “Winston-Salem/Forsyth Co. Planning & Zoning,” would amend a 1947 local law governing Winston-Salem’s planning and zoning. Its stated aim is to let the City delegate rezoning authority to the joint City-County Planning Board while keeping appeal rights and final review with the City Council. The bill has been introduced and is not law.

  • The City may, by ordinance, give the joint board authority to rezone property, including to approve site plan amendments. The bill does not itself delegate that authority.
  • Before delegating, the City Council must set rules, regulations, and guidelines for the board, and provide rights of appeal and final review.
  • The bill changes references to the “Board of Aldermen” to “City Council” and says those terms have the same meaning.
  • The bill applies only to Winston-Salem. It does not itself rezone any property or change the housing incentives and other zoning powers also set out in the amended section.

What it means for you#

  • People seeking a rezoning or site plan amendment: If the City adopts an ordinance delegating authority, the joint board may decide those matters, subject to the appeal and final-review process the City Council must provide. The bill does not set out an application process or say who may appeal.
  • Residents affected by land-use decisions: The decision-maker could change from the City Council to the joint board if the City chooses to delegate. The bill does not specify how residents would take part in the board’s decisions.
  • City Council and joint board: The Council must establish rules before delegating. The board would receive only the authority the City grants by ordinance.
  • Forsyth County: The bill applies to the City of Winston-Salem, though the board named in it is a joint City-County board. It does not generally change county zoning authority.

Money#

No cost information is available in the supplied material.

  • The bill contains no appropriation or cost estimate.
  • It does not specify staffing, administrative costs, or whether the City or County would pay for any added work.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not say what rules the City must adopt, who may appeal, or how the Council’s final review would work.
  • It does not set timelines, public-participation steps, or other procedures for board decisions.
  • It does not explain how the City’s delegated authority would interact with the joint board’s existing role.
  • The full current text of the 1947 law was not supplied, so the comparison with current law is limited to the text shown in the bill. The supplied text indicates the board can recommend zoning changes and prepare zoning rules; it does not show it currently has authority to decide rezonings.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that a planning board already involved in zoning could also decide rezoning matters if the City chooses.
  • The Council would have to set rules first and provide appeal rights and final review, keeping a City Council review role.
  • Delegation is optional, so the City would not have to use it.

Case against#

  • The bill does not set minimum standards for the rules the City must adopt, leaving important safeguards and procedures to a later City ordinance.
  • It is unclear who could appeal and what “final review” would involve, making the limits on the board’s decision-making power hard to assess.
  • The bill does not explain how the joint board’s new authority would affect public participation or the division of work between the City and County.