Urges carbon capture for oil recovery

Summary#

HCR 3016 is a North Dakota concurrent resolution, not a bill that amends a statute or creates a program. The supplied status calls it enacted, but its text recognizes claimed benefits of enhanced oil recovery and urges state and federal action; it does not itself impose new policy requirements. Its stated goal is to advance energy security.

  • The resolution encourages North Dakota and the federal government to maintain policies supporting carbon capture and the use of carbon dioxide as a commodity.
  • It urges the federal government to develop policies that encourage and incentivize using carbon dioxide for enhanced oil recovery, and to increase its partnership with North Dakota and energy industries on carbon capture and enhanced oil recovery in the Bakken Formation.
  • It directs the North Dakota Secretary of State to send copies to the U.S. President, the Secretaries of Energy and the Interior, and North Dakota’s congressional delegation.

What it means for you#

  • North Dakota residents and taxpayers: The resolution does not change taxes, benefits, services, or property rights.
  • Energy companies and carbon-capture developers: The resolution expresses legislative support, but does not itself provide funding, tax incentives, permits, or a right to use carbon dioxide.
  • State and federal officials: It urges policy action, but does not set a deadline or require them to adopt particular policies.

Money#

No publicly available information on the cost of carrying out the resolution.

  • It does not appropriate money or create a grant, tax incentive, fee, or fine.
  • It asks the federal government to consider policies that incentivize carbon dioxide use; it does not create those incentives.
  • The resolution cites industry revenue, jobs, and tax figures, but these are claims in its recitals, not estimates of the resolution’s costs or effects.

What is unclear#

  • “Favorable policies” is not defined, and the resolution does not specify which policies should be maintained or changed.
  • It gives no details about what federal incentives or expanded government-industry partnerships should involve.
  • It sets no process, funding, timeline, oversight, or measures for evaluating carbon capture or enhanced oil recovery.
  • The resolution cites potential oil production and economic benefits but provides no supporting analysis in the supplied material.

Case for#

  • The resolution’s stated rationale is that enhanced oil recovery could produce more oil from the Bakken and extend production.
  • It presents captured carbon dioxide as a commodity that could support enhanced oil recovery, linking carbon capture with continued energy production.
  • It argues that supporting these technologies could benefit North Dakota’s energy industries, jobs, tax base, and energy security.

Case against#

  • The resolution asks governments to support carbon dioxide use for more oil production without setting conditions or explaining how competing goals would be weighed.
  • It gives no cost estimate or plan for any incentives or expanded partnerships that might follow.
  • Its claims about additional oil, longer production, and economic benefits are not assessed in the supplied material.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 1491442

    Passed90 members voted

    House Second reading, adopted yeas 67 nays 23

    FOR · 67AGAINST · 23

    67For

    • Republican57
    • Democratic10

    23Against

    • Republican22
    • Democratic1

    4 members were paired and sat out the vote.