Coal-focused resolution seeks federal energy changes

Summary#

HCR 3017 is a North Dakota concurrent resolution; it does not amend an existing Act or create a new operating program. It recognizes December 6 as annual “Miner’s Day” and urges changes to federal energy and environmental policy. Its stated goal is to honor coal miners and support coal-based energy and the state’s energy security.

  • It asks the federal government to avoid rules it says could threaten reliable, affordable electricity, and to support base-load power (electricity supplied steadily), new generation, and technology for future lignite plants.
  • It urges the federal government to review and repeal the 2009 Endangerment Finding, and to revise policies it says disadvantage coal.
  • It asks federal agencies to work more with North Dakota on critical and rare earth minerals, carbon capture, and other technologies, with the stated aim of supporting coal facilities while reducing emissions.
  • It asks the Secretary of State to send copies to the President, several federal agency heads, and North Dakota’s congressional delegation.

What it means for you#

  • Coal miners and the public: December 6 is recognized as an annual day to honor coal miners. The resolution does not make it a public holiday or require anyone to hold events.
  • Federal agencies and officials: The resolution urges them to take specified actions, but it does not itself change federal regulations or require them to respond.
  • North Dakota Secretary of State: The resolution directs the Secretary to forward copies to the named federal officials and members of Congress.
  • Electricity users and businesses: It does not directly change electricity rates, energy supply, taxes, or environmental requirements.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The resolution does not state an appropriation or funding amount.
  • It directs the Secretary of State to send copies, but gives no estimate for that work.
  • It asks for more federal agency partnership and research, but does not provide funding or staffing details.

What is unclear#

  • The resolution does not define what activities, if any, should mark Miner’s Day.
  • It does not identify which federal rules should be changed beyond naming the 2009 Endangerment Finding and broadly referring to policies that disadvantage coal.
  • It does not describe what a replacement regulatory approach would require or how it would address environmental concerns.
  • It gives no process, timetable, funding, or specific commitments for federal agency partnerships.
  • The resolution’s economic, energy, and environmental statements are claims in its preamble; the supplied material does not independently verify them.

Case for#

  • The resolution recognizes coal miners’ work and the role the resolution says lignite coal plays in North Dakota’s economy and electricity supply.
  • A possible argument for it is that research and development in carbon capture and critical minerals could support new uses for lignite while reducing emissions.
  • It could be seen as asking federal agencies to work with the state and industry on rules that account for available technology and economic feasibility.

Case against#

  • The resolution urges broad federal policy changes without saying exactly which rules should change or what replacement safeguards should apply.
  • One concern is that urging repeal of the Endangerment Finding without specifying a replacement could leave important environmental protections uncertain.
  • The resolution asks for more research and agency partnership but provides no funding, timeline, or measures of success.
  • Its requests do not require federal officials to act, so the changes it seeks may not follow from the resolution.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 1492935

    Passed89 members voted

    House Second reading, adopted yeas 84 nays 5

    FOR · 84AGAINST · 5

    84For

    • Republican78
    • Democratic6

    5Against

    • Democratic5

    5 members were paired and sat out the vote.