Study of property rights in Uniform Commercial Code

Summary#

SB 2364 would not amend the Uniform Commercial Code or change anyone’s property rights. It would require North Dakota’s Legislative Management to consider studying certain property rights and dispute jurisdiction; the stated purpose is to report findings and recommendations to the 2027 legislative assembly. The bill failed to pass, so it did not become law.

  • The Legislative Management would have to consider whether to study property rights of “entitlement holders” in Uniform Commercial Code transactions and jurisdiction over disputes with securities intermediaries.
  • If it undertook the study, it would have to review the Uniform Commercial Code, including Article 8, in relation to state and federal law and their interaction on ownership of personal property.
  • The study would have to seek input from relevant stakeholders, including securities intermediaries.
  • The Legislative Management would have to report findings and recommendations, and any legislation needed to carry them out, to the next legislative assembly.

What it means for you#

  • People who hold securities through an intermediary: The bill would not change your ownership rights or create a way to bring or resolve disputes. It concerns a possible study of those topics.
  • Securities intermediaries: They would be among the groups the study must seek input from if it is undertaken. The bill does not require them to provide information or take other action.
  • North Dakota residents and taxpayers: The bill would not create a new service, benefit, fee, or tax. It failed to pass, so it creates no current duty to study or report.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill does not state a study budget, staffing level, or other cost estimate.

What is unclear#

  • The bill requires the Legislative Management to consider studying the issue; it does not clearly require it to conduct the study.
  • “Entitlement holders” and “relevant stakeholders” are not defined.
  • The bill does not set out how the study would be conducted or how people other than the named securities intermediaries could provide input.
  • The supplied material does not explain the current law on these property rights or dispute jurisdiction.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that a study could examine how state and federal law interact on ownership of personal property in these transactions.
  • Seeking input from securities intermediaries could give the study information from parties involved in those transactions.
  • Reporting recommendations, including any proposed legislation, would give lawmakers a basis for deciding whether a legal change is needed.

Case against#

  • The bill does not guarantee that a study would happen: it requires the Legislative Management to consider studying the issue.
  • Even if a study were undertaken, the bill would not itself resolve disputes or change property rights.
  • The bill gives no cost estimate and does not set out the study’s methods or how input would be gathered.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 1498542

    Defeated47 members voted

    Senate Second reading

    AGAINST · 27FOR · 20

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    27Against

    • Republican25
    • Democratic2

    20For

    • Republican17
    • Democratic3