Legacy Fund Earnings Redirected to Debt and Roads

Summary#

SB 2372, titled “Legacy fund definitions and a legacy earnings fund,” would amend North Dakota law, repeal two existing sections, and create a new section governing legacy-fund earnings. Its apparent goal is to direct those earnings to debt service, tax-relief initiatives, highways and strategic investments. The bill failed to pass, so it did not become law.

  • The state treasurer would have to transfer 8% of the Legacy Fund’s five-year average value to a new Legacy Earnings Fund every July in an odd-numbered year.
  • The treasurer would have to allocate seven-eighths of that transfer in a set order: first to debt service, then to the General Fund for tax-relief initiatives approved by the Legislature, then to a highway fund, and then between the General Fund and the Strategic Investment and Improvements Fund.
  • The remaining one-eighth would go to the highway fund.
  • The State Investment Board would invest the new fund, subject to existing law governing its investments.
  • The bill would repeal two sections about Legacy Fund definitions and a Legacy Earnings Fund. The parent sections were not supplied, so it is not possible to verify which existing rules the bill would change or replace.

What it means for you#

  • State government: If enacted, the state treasurer would have a duty to make the transfers and allocations. The bill would not itself choose specific tax cuts; the Legislature would have to approve the tax-relief initiatives.
  • Drivers, transit users, and local governments: The highway fund would distribute its money as follows: 60% to the Department of Transportation for the state highway fund; 10% to township highway aid; 1.5% to public transportation; and 28.5% to cities and counties for roadway purposes.
  • Taxpayers: The bill would not directly reduce anyone’s taxes. It would send part of the money to the General Fund for tax-relief initiatives that the Legislature approves.
  • Individuals: The bill does not create a direct payment, benefit, application process, or new service for individuals.

Money#

No cost estimate is included in the supplied material. No publicly available information.

  • The bill would direct a share of Legacy Fund earnings to specified state funds; it does not state a dollar total for future transfers.
  • The debt-service allocation would be capped at the lesser of $102,624,000 or the amount appropriated from the Legacy Sinking and Interest Fund for debt service for that two-year period.
  • The bill would direct $225 million to the General Fund for approved tax-relief initiatives and the next $100 million to the highway fund, subject to how much is available under the allocation formula.
  • The bill does not give an estimate for administrative or investment costs.

What is unclear#

  • The existing sections being repealed and the current versions of the amended laws were not supplied. I cannot verify how the proposed formula compares with current law or how much of the wording is new.
  • The bill does not say which tax-relief initiatives would receive funding; that would require later legislative approval.
  • It refers to another law for how the Strategic Investment and Improvements Fund may be used, but that law was not supplied.
  • The bill does not provide an estimate of future distributions or investment and administrative costs.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it sets a regular formula for using Legacy Fund earnings rather than leaving each allocation to be decided separately.
  • The formula directs money to several stated purposes: debt service, tax-relief initiatives, highways, and strategic investments.
  • The five-year average is specified as the basis for calculating the transfer, which may make the amount less dependent on a single year’s fund balance.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the formula would direct 8% of the fund’s five-year average value out of the Legacy Fund every two years, leaving less of that amount in the fund for investment.
  • The bill assigns fixed portions to several uses, which could limit the Legislature’s flexibility to use that money for other needs.
  • The bill does not specify what tax-relief initiatives would be funded, so the purpose of that General Fund allocation would depend on later decisions.
  • Without the current versions of the repealed sections, it is unclear whether the bill changes existing allocations substantially or mainly moves rules into a new section.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 1498475

    Defeated47 members voted

    Senate Second reading

    AGAINST · 47

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    47Against

    • Republican42
    • Democratic5

    0For