Pull-tab maintenance rules and dog racing changes

Summary#

SB 2384 would amend four sections of the North Dakota Century Code; it would not create a new law separate from that Code. Its stated goals are to set rules for maintaining electronic pull tab devices and eliminate dog racing.

  • A manufacturer may work directly with a licensed gaming organization on maintenance and technical or software problems with an electronic pull tab device.
  • A device’s distributor or manufacturer must tell the organization about scheduled maintenance or repair and allow an organization representative to be present.
  • The bill also changes racing-law provisions. Sections 2, 3, and 4 are stated to take effect August 1, 2027.
  • The supplied text is difficult to reconcile: it still contains references to simulcast dog racing, while the title says dog racing would be eliminated. The precise legal change is unclear from this text.

What it means for you#

  • Licensed gaming organizations: A manufacturer may work with you directly on device maintenance and technical or software issues. For scheduled maintenance or repair, the distributor or manufacturer must notify you and allow your representative to be present. The bill does not set a notice period or explain how unscheduled repairs are handled.
  • Manufacturers and distributors: You would have to give notice of scheduled maintenance or repair and allow an organization representative to attend. The bill does not specify a penalty for failing to do so.
  • Racing businesses and bettors: The bill is titled as eliminating dog racing and changes provisions about racing licenses and wagering. But the supplied text retains references to simulcast dog racing, so it does not let readers determine exactly what dog-racing activity would be prohibited or allowed.
  • Other gaming license fees: The bill text reproduces licensing and stamp-fee provisions, but the supplied material does not show which of those amounts, if any, would change.

Money#

No publicly available information.

  • The supplied material gives no estimate of government spending, savings, or costs to gaming organizations or racing businesses.
  • It reproduces license and stamp fees, but does not make clear whether the bill changes them.
  • The bill creates a notice and representative-presence duty for device maintenance, but gives no estimate of the cost of complying.

What is unclear#

  • The bill text supplied does not show the deleted and added wording clearly. This makes the dog-racing amendments hard to interpret, especially because dog-racing references remain in the printed text.
  • The current versions of the amended Code sections were not supplied, so it is not possible to verify which wording is new and which rules already apply.
  • The bill does not set timelines or a process for maintenance notices, explain how unscheduled repairs are treated, or state how the new duty would be enforced.
  • The supplied text specifies an August 1, 2027 effective date for the racing amendments, but does not give an effective date for the electronic pull tab maintenance provision.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the maintenance rules is that organizations would know when scheduled repairs are happening and could have a representative present.
  • Allowing manufacturers to work directly with organizations may help address technical or software issues without requiring all communication to go through a distributor.
  • If the racing amendments do eliminate dog racing as the title says, a possible argument is that the bill would remove dog racing from the state’s racing system. The supplied text does not make the scope of that change clear.

Case against#

  • The dog-racing wording is difficult to reconcile. If the operative text still permits some dog-racing activity, the bill may not achieve the elimination described in its title.
  • The maintenance duties do not include notice deadlines, rules for urgent repairs, or a stated consequence for non-compliance. Organizations and businesses may therefore have uncertainty about how the duties would work.
  • The bill supplies no cost estimate, so the financial effect of the maintenance requirements and racing changes cannot be assessed from the available material.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 1495874

    Passed47 members voted

    Senate Second reading

    FOR · 24AGAINST · 23

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    24For

    • Republican21
    • Democratic3

    23Against

    • Republican21
    • Democratic2