Mobile home parks face receivership and eviction defenses

Summary#

SB 2385 is enacted, according to the supplied status. It amends North Dakota laws on mobile home parks and other licensed parks, and creates rules for court-appointed receivers and a defense to mobile-home-park evictions. Its stated goal is not provided in the supplied material.

  • If the Department of Health and Human Services revokes a mobile home park’s license, it may ask a court to put the park under a receiver for repeated or serious violations, or to protect health or safety. The court may appoint the department commissioner; the commissioner may designate a qualified individual or nonprofit to run the receivership.
  • A receiver must use the park’s income and assets to operate it and try to correct violations or health and safety threats, but may not liquidate its assets. The receivership ends under specified conditions, including correction of the problems and restoration or issue of a license.
  • The bill sets licensing requirements and inspection powers for mobile home parks, recreational vehicle parks and campgrounds. It also requires license holders and new owners to provide certain ownership and manager contact details.
  • The amended text sets park-owner duties toward tenants, including notices, access to lease terms, utility-charge limits and limits on late fees. It also allows a tenant to raise certain violations as a defense in an eviction case.
  • The bill changes penalties for some licensing and tenant-rights violations, including possible fines, damages, legal costs and court-ordered license suspension.

The supplied material does not include the prior versions of the amended laws, so I could not verify which of these duties or protections are new or changed from existing law.

What it means for you#

  • Mobile home park tenants: The amended text requires owners to provide specified contact information and notice of ownership changes, and to acknowledge tenant complaints within two business days. Tenants may request a copy of lease terms. The bill also sets limits on utility charges and late fees and provides notice and time to address certain rule changes. I could not verify which of these protections already existed.
  • Tenants facing eviction: A tenant may raise an owner’s violation of the mobile-home-park requirements as a defense. If the court finds a violation, it may not order eviction. In a later eviction case between the same parties, the tenant’s defense is limited to violations arising after the earlier order or violations the court did not know about then.
  • Park owners and operators: The text requires licensing and calls for specified applications and ownership or manager information. It provides for civil penalties for some violations and says operating without a license, or during a suspension, is an infraction. The Department may inspect parks at reasonable times; the text does not require an inspection of every park on a set schedule.
  • Owners facing receivership: A receiver can operate the park and use its income and assets to address problems, but cannot sell off its assets. The text does not set out a process for residents to apply for a receiver.
  • Department and courts: The Department may seek a receiver after revoking a park license. Courts decide whether to grant the petition and may suspend a park license for violations of tenant protections.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s total public or private cost.

  • The bill provides for license and inspection fees, civil penalties and other possible costs, but gives no estimate of revenue or spending.
  • A receiver must use the park’s income and assets to operate the park and address problems. The bill does not say how much a receivership would cost or who would cover any shortfall.
  • Some violations may bring a civil penalty of up to $5,000 per violation, or a $100-per-day penalty for operating without a license, capped at $10,000. The text also provides for other penalties and legal costs in tenant-rights cases.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the current versions of the amended laws, so it does not show how much of the tenant and licensing language changes existing law.
  • The bill text does not give a start date.
  • It does not define “serious” violations or explain how the court should assess whether health or safety is seriously threatened.
  • It does not set out how a receiver is chosen, paid or supervised beyond the stated court role and accounting at the end of the receivership.
  • The civil-penalty text includes procedures for notice and hearings but does not clearly explain how those procedures fit together.

Case for#

  • A receiver could keep a park operating while serious safety or health problems are addressed, rather than requiring the park’s assets to be sold.
  • Clear owner and manager contact details, complaint acknowledgements and access to lease terms could make it easier for tenants to contact the responsible person and understand their agreements.
  • The eviction defense could prevent an eviction order when a court finds the landlord violated the stated tenant protections.
  • Licensing and inspection powers could give the Department tools to address unsafe conditions and unlicensed operations.

Case against#

  • The bill gives the Department and courts significant roles in park operation and licensing, but does not fully explain how receivers will be selected, supervised or funded.
  • Some key standards, including what counts as a “serious” violation, are not defined in the supplied text.
  • The amended text creates or restates many tenant and licensing rules, but without the prior law it is unclear which protections are new and how they fit with existing requirements.
  • Penalties, damages and court-ordered license suspension could impose substantial costs on park owners; the materials do not estimate those costs or explain their likely scale.

Votes

2 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 1550604

    Passed47 members voted

    Senate Second reading

    FOR · 47

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    47For

    • Republican42
    • Democratic5

    0Against

  2. Division No. 1491612

    Passed45 members voted

    Senate Second reading

    FOR · 45

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    45For

    • Republican40
    • Democratic5

    0Against

    2 members were paired and sat out the vote.