Push for Electoral College pact gains traction

Summary#

SCR-4013 is an enacted North Dakota concurrent resolution supporting the Electoral College and opposing the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact. It does not amend an election law or create the proposed Electoral College Interstate Compact; it sets out North Dakota’s position and a conditional proposal for states to form that compact. Its stated goal is to respond to the National Popular Vote compact.

  • The Legislature expresses support for the Electoral College and says the National Popular Vote compact may be unconstitutional. That is the resolution’s position, not a court ruling.
  • North Dakota proposes forming an Electoral College Interstate Compact once four other states declare that they intend to join.
  • The proposed compact would prohibit requiring member-state electors to vote according to the national popular vote count, and would require member states to legally challenge the National Popular Vote compact’s constitutionality.
  • The Secretary of State must send copies of the resolution to the named states’ secretaries of state and legislative leaders.

What it means for you#

  • North Dakota residents: The resolution does not itself change how presidential electoral votes are awarded or require electors to vote a particular way.
  • North Dakota Secretary of State: The resolution directs the Secretary to send copies to officials in the states it lists.
  • Other states: The resolution invites them to consider the proposed compact. It does not make them members or require them to join.
  • Taxpayers: No new tax, fee, fine, benefit, or public service is created in the resolution.

Money#

No publicly available information on cost is included in the supplied material.

  • The resolution requires the Secretary of State to send copies, but gives no estimate of the cost.
  • It does not specify funding or staffing for organizing the proposed compact.

What is unclear#

  • The resolution does not set out the proposed compact’s full legal text or explain how states would organize it.
  • It does not explain how the condition of four other states declaring intent would be confirmed, or when North Dakota would take the next steps.
  • It does not explain what “appropriate steps” to organize and form the compact would involve.
  • The resolution does not establish whether the proposed compact would take legal effect, or how it would interact with existing state or federal election law.

Case for#

  • The resolution’s stated concern is that the National Popular Vote compact could reduce the role of individual states and lead to nationwide recounts or greater federal control of elections.
  • A possible argument for the proposal is that a group of states could jointly defend the role of state electors and challenge the other compact’s constitutionality.
  • The resolution presents the Electoral College as a way to balance state and regional interests in presidential elections.

Case against#

  • The resolution does not establish the proposed compact or show that other states will join, so its proposed response may not lead to a working agreement.
  • The resolution calls the National Popular Vote compact’s constitutionality doubtful but does not provide a legal ruling establishing that it is unconstitutional.
  • It does not explain the costs, process, or legal consequences of organizing a compact or bringing a legal challenge.