End the disadvantaged business enterprise program

Summary#

SCR 4021 is an enacted North Dakota concurrent resolution, not a bill that changes an existing law. It urges federal and state officials to end the disadvantaged business enterprise (DBE) program; its stated goal is to remove DBE and related diversity, equity, and inclusion policies from government activity.

  • The resolution encourages the federal Department of Government Efficiency to take steps to eliminate the DBE program and related DEI programs.
  • It encourages North Dakota’s congressional delegation to work to remove DEI policies and requirements from funding to states.
  • It supports the Governor ending the North Dakota Department of Transportation’s DBE program as soon as federal law allows.
  • It supports the North Dakota Attorney General taking available legal action against DBE requirements and practices in the state.
  • It requires the Secretary of State to send copies of the resolution to named federal and state officials.

What it means for you#

  • Businesses and contractors: The resolution does not itself change who can qualify for DBE status, how contracts are awarded, or what contractors must do. If officials act on its requests, the program or its requirements could change, but this resolution does not set out those changes.
  • North Dakota officials: The Governor and Attorney General are encouraged, not required, to take the actions described. The Secretary of State must send the resolution to the listed recipients.
  • Federal officials: The resolution asks federal officials and Congress to act, but it does not bind them.
  • General public: It does not itself end the DBE program, change contract awards, or create a new legal right, ban, or penalty.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The resolution does not appropriate money or set a fee, fine, or spending amount.
  • It claims the DBE program raises contractor costs and taxpayer costs, but the supplied material provides no figures or evidence to measure those claims.
  • Any costs or savings from later action to change or end the program are unknown.

What is unclear#

  • The resolution does not explain which DBE rules or related programs officials should remove.
  • It does not set a timeline or process for officials to act, or say how the program would operate while any changes are considered.
  • It does not explain what ending the state program would mean for businesses currently covered by it or for contract awards.
  • The resolution refers to federal law as a limit on when the Governor could end the state program but does not explain that limit.
  • Its statements about costs, competition, and the court case are claims in the resolution; the supplied material does not provide supporting detail to assess them.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the resolution is that, if DBE requirements add costs or deter bids as it claims, ending them could reduce burdens on contractors and taxpayers.
  • The resolution favors awarding construction contracts based on the lowest responsible bid rather than race, sex, or presumed social disadvantage.
  • It asks officials to seek changes through federal action, state executive action where federal law allows, and available legal action.

Case against#

  • The resolution does not show how much the DBE program costs or establish that removing it would lower bids or save taxpayers money.
  • It calls for ending a program without explaining what would replace it or how businesses covered by the program would be affected.
  • It encourages action by several officials but sets no timeline, process, or measure for judging the results.
  • The resolution itself does not change the program, so its practical effects depend on later decisions by officials it cannot compel.