Home value increases exempt from property tax

Summary#

HJR 10 proposes adding a section to the Ohio Constitution; it does not amend an existing statute. Its goal is to exempt some increases in the appraised value of eligible homes from property taxation. It is introduced, not law: it would need approval by three-fifths of each chamber of the General Assembly and then a majority of voters. The proposal sets a May 4, 2027 election date; if voters approve it, the exemption would begin January 1, 2028.

  • For an eligible homestead, the amount of current appraised value above the value for the tax year before the latest countywide reappraisal or update, adjusted for inflation, would be exempt.
  • The exemption would apply only while the home is owned by the same individual or that person’s spouse.
  • “Homestead” includes a manufactured or mobile home owned and occupied as a home by an Ohio-domiciled individual.
  • New improvements generally would not qualify. An improvement that repairs or replaces damage could qualify, up to the amount of a valuation deduction allowed for that damage.

What it means for you#

  • Eligible homeowners: A qualifying increase in your home’s appraised value would be left out of the property-tax base. The proposal does not promise a particular dollar reduction in your tax bill.
  • Homeowners who add to a home: The value of a permanent addition, enlargement, or alteration generally would not be exempt. The exception is a repair or replacement for damage that had qualified for a valuation deduction, and the exemption would be capped at that deduction.
  • Local taxing entities and taxpayers: The exemption could reduce the value on which property taxes are assessed. The proposal does not provide replacement funding or change tax rates.
  • Other residents: The proposal does not create a direct payment, a new tax rate, or a general exemption for all property.

Money#

No cost or revenue estimate is included in the supplied material.

  • The proposal would remove qualifying home value from the property-tax base, which could reduce property-tax revenue.
  • It does not specify state payments to replace any lost local revenue, or give staffing or administrative cost estimates.

What is unclear#

  • The proposal does not set out application, verification, appeal, or administration rules.
  • It does not explain how the exemption would interact with existing Ohio homestead exemptions or other property-tax rules. The supplied material does not include current law, so that interaction could not be checked.
  • It does not explain how the exemption would apply in situations such as a change in ownership other than to a spouse.
  • It defines the inflation calculation but does not give examples of how assessors would apply it in practice.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the proposal is that it would limit property taxation on qualifying increases in appraised value, while allowing for inflation.
  • The exemption would be tied to continued ownership by the same individual or spouse, rather than applying to every later owner.
  • The proposal keeps ordinary new improvements taxable, while allowing a limited exception for repairs or replacements after damage.

Case against#

  • One concern is that exempting appraised value could reduce local tax revenue, while the proposal provides no replacement funding.
  • The same-owner condition means the exemption would not continue under the proposal after a transfer to someone other than the owner’s spouse.
  • The proposal leaves administration and appeals to be addressed elsewhere, so homeowners and local officials would not know from this text how eligibility would be verified or disputes resolved.