Summary#
Bill 112, the End the Public Funding of Partisan Government Advertising Act, 2017, would amend Ontario’s Government Advertising Act, 2004. Its stated goal is to limit partisan government advertising through rules for Auditor General reviews and election-period restrictions. The bill says it would reverse 2015 changes, but the current Act was not supplied, so the exact changes from current law could not be verified.
- Government offices could not publish, distribute or convey an item before receiving the Auditor General’s review result. They also could not use an item the Auditor General says fails the standards.
- The Auditor General must review items submitted for review against standards including that they serve a listed public-information or promotion purpose, identify the Government of Ontario as payer, and are not partisan or aimed mainly at helping the governing party or hurting its critics.
- The standards generally bar an item from including an Ontario cabinet member’s or MPP’s name, voice or image. That rule would not apply when the item’s main target audience is outside Ontario.
- During specified general-election periods, government offices could not use items even if they passed review, except for revenue-generating or time-sensitive items, or items meeting other criteria set by regulation. Existing items must stop unless the office head thinks stopping them is not practicable.
- If the Auditor General does not give a result within a deadline set by regulation, the item is deemed to meet the standards. A revised item that failed review must be submitted for another review before use.
What it means for you#
- Government offices: They could use only items that pass review, are deemed to pass because the deadline was missed, or qualify for an election-period exception. The bill does not say in the supplied text which items must be submitted for review.
- Ontario residents: The bill would not end government-funded advertising. It would set standards and election-period limits on certain government advertising and messages.
- Taxpayers: The bill does not create a new benefit, tax, fee or fine, or set an advertising budget.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The Auditor General would have a duty to review items submitted for review. The bill gives no estimate for the staff time or other costs involved.
- The bill does not set spending, savings or revenue amounts.
What is unclear#
- The current Government Advertising Act was not supplied, so the precise difference between this bill and current law could not be checked.
- The bill leaves review deadlines, some standards, and some factors for regulations. Those details are not in the supplied material.
- The bill does not set out which items must be submitted, how the Auditor General’s review is carried out, or any appeal process.
- It does not define “time sensitive” or when it is “not practicable” to stop an existing item.
- The bill would start on a date set by proclamation; no start date is given.
Case for#
- The review rules could help keep government-paid items focused on public purposes rather than the governing party’s political interests.
- Requiring the payer to be named and barring politicians’ names, voices or images could make the source of advertising clearer and limit its use to promote individual politicians.
- Election-period restrictions could reduce government advertising near an election, while exceptions allow some revenue-related or time-sensitive communications.
- Having the Auditor General review items could provide an independent check.
Case against#
- The Auditor General could consider additional factors, and regulations would set some standards and deadlines. The bill does not provide those details, leaving important parts of the rules unsettled.
- If the review deadline is missed, an item is deemed to pass. That could allow an item to be used without a review result.
- The election-period exceptions and the office head’s judgment about whether stopping an existing item is practicable could leave room for different decisions.
- The bill requires review work but gives no cost estimate or detail about the resources needed.