Summary#
Bill 7, the End the Public Funding of Partisan Government Advertising Act, 2018, would amend Ontario’s Government Advertising Act, 2004. Its stated goal is to prevent public money being used for partisan government advertising; the bill’s explanatory note says it would largely restore the Act’s rules as they stood before 2015 amendments.
- Government offices would have to wait for the Auditor General’s review result before using an advertisement, printed item or message. They could not use it if the Auditor General says it fails the Act’s standards.
- Items would have to serve one of four listed public purposes, say they were paid for by the Government of Ontario, and not be partisan or mainly intended to improve the governing party’s image or damage its critics.
- Government items generally could not include an elected member’s name, voice or image. That restriction would not apply when the primary audience is outside Ontario.
- Government offices generally could not use items during specified general-election periods, including the 60 days before the writ for a fixed-date general election. Exceptions would cover revenue-generating or time-sensitive items, and any other prescribed criteria.
- The Auditor General would review items submitted and notify the government office within a time limit to be set by regulation. If notice is late, the item would be deemed to meet the standards.
What it means for you#
- Government offices: They would have to hold items until the review result arrives, and would have to stop using items that receive an adverse result. A revised item would also need another review before use.
- The Auditor General’s Office: It would review submitted items and judge whether they meet the standards. The bill lets the Auditor General consider factors set by regulation and other factors the Auditor General considers appropriate when deciding whether an item is partisan.
- The public: This would not ban government advertising. Items could still inform people about policies, programs, services, legal rights or responsibilities, encourage or discourage behaviour in the public interest, or promote Ontario and its economy, if they meet the standards.
- During election periods: Offices would generally have to stop ongoing advertising too. But the office head could decide it is not practicable to stop an item already running, and the bill includes other exceptions.
- The bill does not change voter eligibility, create a public benefit, impose a tax or fine, or create a new agency. The review is assigned to the existing Auditor General’s Office.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The bill would add review and compliance duties for government offices and the Auditor General’s Office, but gives no staffing or cost estimate.
- It does not set a fee, appropriation, fine or funding program.
What is unclear#
- The supplied material does not include the current Government Advertising Act, 2004. The explanatory note describes the bill as reversing 2015 amendments, but the exact current-law comparison could not be verified.
- The bill leaves the review deadlines to regulations; it does not set the number of days.
- The bill does not explain the review process beyond the Auditor General’s decision and notice. It gives no appeal process or reporting requirement.
- “Time sensitive” and “revenue-generating activity” are not defined in the bill. Other election-period exceptions can be set by regulation.
- The bill would start only on a day set by proclamation. No start date is supplied.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that public funds should pay for useful government information, not advertising whose main purpose is to help the governing party or harm its critics.
- Requiring review before use could prevent an item judged non-compliant from being published or broadcast in the first place.
- The listed purposes and requirement to identify government payment could help distinguish public information from partisan promotion.
- Limits during election periods could reduce the use of government advertising around elections, while exceptions preserve some time-sensitive or revenue-generating messages.
Case against#
- The bill gives the Auditor General room to consider factors beyond those set by regulation when judging whether an item is partisan. The bill does not spell out all those factors or provide an appeal process.
- If the review deadline is missed, the item is deemed to meet the standards. The bill does not set that deadline itself.
- The election-period exceptions, including the office head’s judgment that stopping an existing item is not practicable, could leave room for different decisions about which items continue.
- The bill adds review duties but does not estimate the staff or public money needed to carry them out.