End Public Funding of Partisan Ads

Summary#

Bill 101, End the Public Funding of Partisan Government Advertising Act, 2019, would amend Ontario’s Government Advertising Act, 2004. Its stated goal is to end public funding of partisan government advertising; the bill does this by setting review standards and restricting when government offices may use ads, printed material and messages. The explanatory note says it would reverse changes made in 2015, but the parent Act was not supplied, so I could not verify how the bill’s rules compare with current law.

  • The Auditor General must review an item sent for review and decide whether, in the Auditor General’s opinion, it meets the bill’s standards.
  • A government office must not use an item before it receives the review result. It must not use an item the Auditor General finds fails the standards.
  • Items must serve at least one listed public purpose, say they were paid for by the Government of Ontario, and not include an Ontario cabinet minister’s or MPP’s name, voice or image. That last rule does not apply when the primary target audience is outside Ontario.
  • An item must not be partisan, or have as a primary objective fostering a positive impression of the governing party or a negative impression of its critics. The Auditor General may consider prescribed factors and other factors the Auditor General considers appropriate.
  • Government offices generally could not use items during specified election periods, even if they passed review. Exceptions include revenue-generating or time-sensitive items and any criteria set by regulation. The rules also cover ongoing use, unless the office head thinks stopping it is not practicable.

What it means for you#

  • Government offices: They would face limits on using government-funded ads, printed matter and messages. During specified election periods, they would generally have to stop ongoing use too, subject to the stated exception.
  • Auditor General: The office would have a legal duty to review items and give notice within a period set by regulation. If notice is late, the item is deemed to meet the standards.
  • Ontario residents: You might see fewer government items that fail the standards or fall within the election-period restrictions. The bill does not ban all government advertising or guarantee that every item will be reviewed before use; if the deadline passes without notice, it is deemed to have passed.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill directs the Auditor General’s office to review items, but gives no estimate of staffing or administrative costs.
  • It sets no fee, fine, tax or new funding program.

What is unclear#

  • The bill leaves the review deadline, extra review factors and some election-period exceptions to regulations; those details are not included.
  • It does not define “time sensitive” or set out a process for challenging a review decision.
  • The supplied text does not set out how review submissions work in practice, or say how the rules interact with other government advertising requirements.
  • The bill would start on a date set by proclamation. No start date is provided.
  • Because the parent Act was not supplied, the current review rules and the precise changes from current law could not be checked.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that public money should not pay for advertising that promotes the governing party or targets its critics.
  • Having the Auditor General review items against stated standards could provide an independent check before government offices use them.
  • Election-period restrictions could limit the use of public advertising during a period when partisan advantage is a particular concern.

Case against#

  • The bill gives the Auditor General room to consider factors beyond those set by regulation, while leaving key terms such as “time sensitive” undefined.
  • A government office could be unable to use an item after a failed review, but the bill does not describe an appeal process.
  • The election-period limits could also delay public information that meets the standards, although the bill provides exceptions for some items.
  • If the Auditor General’s office misses the deadline set by regulation, the item is deemed to pass, so the effect of the review depends partly on a deadline not set in the bill.