Summary#
Bill 117, the Peter Kormos Memorial Act (Trillium Gift of Life Network Amendment), 2017, would amend Ontario’s Trillium Gift of Life Network Act. The supplied explanatory note says current law requires consent before tissue is removed; the parent Act was not supplied, so I could not verify that description against the current statute. The bill’s stated goal is to change how post-death tissue removal and use are authorized.
- It would allow tissue to be removed and used after death for medical education, scientific research or therapeutic purposes, including transplant, without first obtaining consent—unless an exception applies.
- A person aged 16 or older could object before death. A parent or guardian could object for a child under 16. In some circumstances, listed relatives or another eligible person could object for someone else.
- The existing Trillium Gift of Life Network would maintain a registry of objections sent to it. The bill would not create a new independent organization.
- Designated facilities would notify the Network when a patient dies or death is imminent, according to the explanatory note. The Network would decide, in consultation with the facility, whether it must contact the patient or a substitute about the right to object; if told to do so, the facility must make reasonable efforts to make contact.
What it means for you#
- People aged 16 or older: If the bill became law, your tissue could be removed and used after death for the listed purposes without your affirmative consent, unless you object or the religious exception applies. You could object in a signed written document delivered to an attending physician or sent to the Network, or orally during your last illness in front of at least two witnesses.
- Children under 16: A parent or guardian could object on the child’s behalf before the child’s death.
- Family and other eligible people: If a person had not objected, or was incapable of objecting while death was imminent, the bill would let specified people object in a set order: spouse; child; parent; sibling; other next of kin; and, in limited cases, the person lawfully holding the body. A person may not object if they have reason to believe the person would not have objected.
- Patients and families at designated facilities: The facility would have to make reasonable efforts to contact them only if the Network says contact is required. The bill does not require contact in every case.
- Taxpayers and the public: The bill would not create a new Network or directly change taxes, fees, or fines.
Money#
No publicly available information on estimated costs.
- The bill assigns duties to the existing Network and designated facilities, but gives no cost estimate or staffing figure.
What is unclear#
- “Prescribed religion, cult, association or group” is not defined in the bill, and the supplied material does not say which groups would qualify.
- The bill does not set out what information people would receive, how objections would be handled in practice, or how the Network would decide whether a facility must make contact.
- The registry covers objections sent to the Network, but the bill does not clearly explain how objections given to a physician or made orally would be recorded there.
- The bill does not state how tissue-specific objections would be communicated to facilities, or how the new rules would interact with other existing programs.
- The bill would start on Royal Assent. The supplied material does not say whether it received Royal Assent.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to make tissue available for transplant, research and medical education without requiring affirmative consent in each case.
- A possible argument for the bill is that an explicit way to object, along with a registry, could let people who do not want donation refuse it while allowing use when no objection is recorded.
- The bill gives a person’s family or other listed people a way to object when the person did not object themselves or could not do so while death was imminent.
Case against#
- A person’s tissue could be used without their affirmative consent. Someone who did not know about the right to object, or did not manage to object, might not have their wishes recorded.
- The bill allows use for education and research as well as therapeutic purposes, including transplant. It does not explain how people would be told about those different uses.
- The Network would decide whether contact is required, and the bill does not spell out the decision rules. Contact is therefore not guaranteed for every patient or family.
- The religious exception and the process for recording objections are not fully explained, which could make it unclear who is covered and whether an objection reaches the right people.