Tissue Donation Consent Reform Bill

Summary#

Bill 84, the Peter Kormos Memorial Act (Saving Organs to Save Lives), 2023, would amend Ontario’s Gift of Life Act and Connecting Care Act, 2019. It would change the default from requiring consent for post-death tissue removal and use to allowing it unless an objection is made, with a separate consent rule for children under 16. Its stated goal is to support tissue removal, donation and use, including for transplant.

  • For people aged 16 or older, tissue could be removed and used after death unless the person or an eligible substitute objects under the bill’s rules.
  • A parent or guardian would have to consent on behalf of a child under 16. Without that consent, tissue could not be removed and used.
  • Ontario Health would have to create and maintain a registry of objections sent to it and of consents for children under 16 sent to it.
  • Ontario Health would decide, in consultation with a designated facility, whether the facility must contact a patient or substitute about an objection or a child’s consent. If Ontario Health says contact is required, the facility must make reasonable efforts to contact them.
  • Ontario Health’s stated functions would expand to include activities related to tissue removal, donation, transplantation and other uses, and support for designated facilities.

What it means for you#

  • Adults: You could object to post-death tissue removal and use before your death, in writing, orally before two witnesses, or by recorded message. You must communicate the objection to an attending physician or Ontario Health.
  • Family and other substitutes: If a person dies without making an objection, or is near death and a physician considers them unable to object, specified people may object. The order is: spouse; a child; a parent; a sibling; another next of kin; then the person lawfully in possession of the body, subject to exclusions in the bill. A person cannot object if they have reason to believe the deceased or dying person would not have objected.
  • Parents and guardians: You would have to consent before tissue could be removed and used after the death of a child under 16. The bill does not set out a separate process for deciding between a child’s parents or guardians.
  • Patients and substitutes in designated facilities: You may be contacted about an objection or a child’s consent if Ontario Health decides the facility must make contact. The bill does not require contact in every case.
  • The public: The bill covers therapeutic purposes, medical education and scientific research, including transplant. It does not guarantee that tissue will be recovered or used in any particular case.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • Ontario Health would have to establish and maintain the registry, but the bill gives no cost estimate or funding amount.
  • Designated facilities would have to make reasonable efforts to contact patients or substitutes when Ontario Health requires it. The bill gives no estimate of staffing or other costs.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “tissue” or set out how Ontario Health would decide when a facility must contact someone.
  • It does not set timelines or a detailed process for objections, consent, registry access, correcting records or resolving disputes.
  • The bill leaves some requirements to Ontario Health and to rules the Minister may prescribe; those requirements are not included here.
  • The registry would record whether an objection or a child’s consent applies to all tissue or specified tissue only if the person making it indicates that. The bill does not explain how that choice would be presented or recorded.
  • The text says the Act would start on Royal Assent. The bill’s current status is not stated in the supplied material: No publicly available information.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that requiring prior consent can prevent tissue from being used when a person’s wishes are not recorded. An objection-based default could allow more tissue to be available, though the bill does not guarantee that outcome.
  • The bill preserves a way for adults to refuse and allows specified substitutes to object in defined circumstances.
  • The registry could help Ontario Health record objections and consents that are sent to it.
  • Requiring consent for children under 16 gives parents or guardians a specific role in those cases.

Case against#

  • The default would change substantially: adults’ tissue could be removed and used without their express consent, unless an objection is made.
  • People may not know how to object or may not have communicated an objection to a physician or Ontario Health. The bill does not set out a public notice or education process.
  • The bill leaves important contact decisions to Ontario Health and provides no detailed criteria or appeal process.
  • The substitute objection rules may create disputes about who can act or what the deceased would have wanted; the bill does not explain how those disputes would be resolved.