Presumed Consent for Tissue Donation

Summary#

Bill 91, the Peter Kormos Memorial Act (Trillium Gift of Life Network Amendment), 2019, would amend Ontario’s Trillium Gift of Life Network Act. It would replace consent as the general condition for post-death tissue use with a system where tissue may be used unless the person or an eligible person objects. The stated goal is to support and coordinate tissue donation, removal and use.

  • The Trillium Gift of Life Network would keep its role and gain duties to coordinate designated facilities’ work and maintain a registry of objections.
  • Tissue could be removed after death for medical education, scientific research or therapeutic purposes, including transplant, unless a listed exception applies or an objection is made.
  • People aged 16 or older could object before death; a parent or guardian could object for a child under 16. Eligible relatives or other listed people could object after death, or when death is imminent and a physician considers the person unable to object.
  • Designated facilities would have to make reasonable efforts to contact a patient or substitute about an objection to tissue removal for transplant if the Network tells them to do so.
  • The bill exempts people who are members, followers or believers of a prescribed religion, cult, association or group. The bill does not define which groups qualify; that depends on what is prescribed.

What it means for you#

  • People who may have tissue removed after death: If no exception applies and no objection is made, the bill would allow tissue removal and use for the listed purposes without consent. It does not require tissue to be removed.
  • People aged 16 or older: You could object in writing, delivered to an attending physician or sent to the Network, or orally before at least two witnesses during your last illness.
  • Children under 16: A parent or guardian could object on the child’s behalf before death.
  • Family and other eligible people: The bill sets an order of who may object for someone else, starting with a spouse, then children, parents, siblings, other next of kin and, in limited cases, the person lawfully in possession of the body. An objector must have no reason to believe the person would not have objected.
  • Hospitals and other designated facilities: According to the explanatory note, facilities must notify the Network when a patient dies or death is imminent. They would also have to make reasonable efforts to ask about an objection to transplant if the Network says contact is required. This is not a requirement to contact every patient or family.
  • The public: The bill changes the default for post-death tissue use; it does not create a requirement to donate or a new independent agency. The Network already exists.

Money#

No publicly available information on costs.

  • The Network would have to establish and maintain an objection registry, and coordinate with designated facilities.
  • Facilities would have to make reasonable efforts to contact patients or substitutes when directed by the Network. The bill gives no staffing or cost estimate and does not state a funding amount.

What is unclear#

  • The parent Act was not supplied, so the current law and the full extent of the changes could not be independently checked against it. The bill’s explanatory note says current law requires consent.
  • The bill does not define “prescribed” religions, cults, associations or groups, or say which ones would be included.
  • The Network determines, in consultation with a facility, whether contact is required for transplant objections. The bill does not set out the criteria for that decision.
  • Objections can be made to an attending physician or orally before witnesses, but the bill does not explain how those objections reach the Network’s registry.
  • The text says the Act would start on Royal Assent. The supplied material does not establish whether the bill received Royal Assent.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it would allow tissue to be used for treatment, research or medical education without first requiring consent, while preserving a way to object.
  • A registry could help the Network and facilities identify objections sent to the Network.
  • The bill allows family members or other listed people to object when the person has not objected and, in some circumstances, cannot do so.
  • The Network’s coordination role could give designated facilities a shared process for asking about transplant objections, while the bill does not require contact in every case.

Case against#

  • One concern is that tissue use would be allowed by default, rather than only after consent. Some people may not know they need to object.
  • The contact duty applies only when the Network tells a facility to make contact, and only to objections about transplant. The bill does not require that contact for every person or address it in the same way for education and research uses.
  • The bill gives the Network a role in deciding whether contact is required, but does not state the decision criteria or set out a review or appeal process.
  • The religious-group exception depends on terms the bill does not define. How it would apply is unclear.