Summary#
Bill 107, the Peter Kormos Memorial Act (Saving Organs to Save Lives), 2022, would amend Ontario’s Gift of Life Act and Connecting Care Act, 2019. Its stated goal is to support the removal, donation and use of human tissue, including transplantation. If enacted, it would change the default for tissue use after death: for people aged 16 or older, consent would generally not be required unless an objection is made.
- Adults aged 16 or older: Tissue could be removed and used after death for treatment, medical education or scientific research, including transplant, unless the person or an eligible substitute objects.
- Children under 16: A parent or guardian must consent to post-death tissue use. Without consent, tissue cannot be removed and used.
- Ontario Health: It would have to coordinate and support tissue-related work and establish and maintain a registry of names linked to objections and parental consents it receives.
- Designated facilities: They must notify Ontario Health when a patient dies or death is imminent, as described in the bill’s explanatory note. If Ontario Health tells a facility to contact the patient or substitute, the facility must make reasonable efforts to do so.
- Family members and others: In specified circumstances, a substitute could object. The bill sets an order of eligible people, from a spouse through other next of kin, with a limited fallback for another lawful possessor of the body.
What it means for you#
- People aged 16 or older: You would not need to register consent for tissue to be used after death. You could object before death, including during your last illness. An objection must be made in writing and signed, orally before at least two witnesses, or by email or another recorded message, and communicated to an attending physician or Ontario Health.
- Family or other substitutes: If the person died without objecting, or death is imminent and a physician says the person cannot object, an eligible substitute could object. The order is spouse, child, parent, sibling, other next of kin, then another lawful possessor of the body, subject to exceptions for certain listed officials and funeral or cremation workers. A substitute cannot object if they have reason to believe the person would not have objected.
- Parents or guardians of children under 16: They would have to consent, and communicate that consent to a physician or Ontario Health, for the child’s tissue to be used after death.
- Designated facilities: If Ontario Health directs them to contact a patient or substitute, they must make reasonable efforts to find out whether there is an objection or, for a child, consent. This does not require contact in every case.
- Other people: The bill does not directly change rules for tissue use while a person is alive.
Money#
No publicly available information on the bill’s cost is included in the supplied materials.
- Ontario Health would have new coordination and registry duties, and designated facilities may have notification and contact work. The bill provides no cost estimate, staffing figure or funding amount.
What is unclear#
- The current versions of the two Acts were not supplied, so the bill’s description of current law could not be independently checked against them.
- The bill does not set out how Ontario Health decides whether a facility must contact a patient or substitute, or what counts as “reasonable efforts.”
- The Minister and Ontario Health would set some contact requirements, but the supplied text does not give those requirements.
- The registry must record names and, if the person submitting the objection or consent indicates it, whether it applies to all tissue or only specified tissue. The bill does not explain who may access the registry or how its information would be protected.
- The text does not explain how an objection or consent sent to a physician, rather than Ontario Health, would be recorded in the registry.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to make tissue available for transplant and other stated uses without requiring adults to give advance consent.
- Allowing objections gives people a way to refuse, while the substitute process gives specified relatives or others a way to object when the person cannot.
- A registry and Ontario Health’s coordination role could help facilities check objections and coordinate tissue-related work.
- Requiring parental consent for children under 16 keeps a consent requirement for that group.
Case against#
- The bill changes the default from consent to no objection. An adult’s tissue could be used without consent being recorded, including for medical education or scientific research as well as transplant.
- A person who dies without objecting may have their tissue used even if their family objects but does not meet the bill’s conditions or order of eligibility.
- Ontario Health and facilities receive new duties, but the bill gives no cost estimate and leaves important contact requirements to later rules or Agency requirements.
- It is unclear how the registry would reflect objections or consents that were communicated to a physician but not sent to Ontario Health.