Summary#
Bill 119, the Fairness in First Contracts and the Right to Representation Act, 2017, would amend Ontario’s Labour Relations Act, 1995. Its title frames its goal as fairness in first contracts and the right to representation; the bill does not guarantee either outcome.
- A union could choose certification without a vote in any industry. The Ontario Labour Relations Board would have to certify it if satisfied that more than 55% of employees in the bargaining unit were union members when the application was filed.
- A party unable to reach a first collective agreement could ask the Minister of Labour to refer the matter to arbitration once 30 days had passed since strikes and lockouts became lawful. If the bill’s conditions were met, the Minister would have to refer it.
- The existing route to ask the Board for first-agreement arbitration would remain, with conditions including a notice or report from the Minister about conciliation.
- A three-member arbitration board would settle the agreement. Each party would appoint one member; those appointees would choose a chair. The Minister would appoint a member or chair if the required appointments were not made.
- Once arbitration began, strikes and lockouts would be prohibited or would have to end. Existing working terms would continue, or be restored if they had changed, until the agreement was settled.
What it means for you#
- Employees and unions: A union could seek certification without a vote if it met the membership threshold. This is not automatic: the Board must be satisfied the threshold is met, and the bill does not require certification below it.
- Employers and unions negotiating a first agreement: Either party could use the new Minister referral route after the 30-day period, if the parties had not reached an agreement. The party seeking arbitration must provide a proposed agreement; the other party must file its own proposed agreement within 10 days.
- Employees and employers in a strike or lockout: If arbitration begins, a strike or lockout must end, and the employer must reinstate employees who were locked out or on strike.
- People seeking to change or end union representation: The bill limits when decertification or displacement applications can proceed during first-agreement arbitration. Some applications would have no effect until after the agreement is settled; the Board would also deal with a pending first-agreement application first in the circumstances set out in the bill.
- General public: The bill changes labour-relations rules; it does not create a new public service or directly change taxes, fees or benefits.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The bill assigns appointment and referral tasks to the Minister and the Board, but gives no staffing or cost estimate.
- It does not say who would pay the arbitration board’s costs.
What is unclear#
- The Labour Relations Act, 1995 is not supplied, so the bill’s changes could not be checked against the full current law. The bill also relies on existing procedural provisions whose details are not included here.
- The bill does not define “unable to enter into a first collective agreement.”
- It does not set a deadline for the arbitration board to finish settling an agreement.
- The materials do not explain how arbitration costs would be divided or whether the new route would add costs for the parties or government.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the no-vote route is that a union with support from more than 55% of the bargaining unit could be certified without holding a vote.
- The Minister route could give either party another way to start first-agreement arbitration after the 30-day period. Once the stated conditions are met, referral is mandatory rather than discretionary.
- Arbitration could settle a first agreement when the parties have been unable to reach one themselves.
Case against#
- Certification without a vote means employees who are not union members would not cast a vote on the application. The bill does not explain in this text how membership is checked or how disagreements about the count are handled.
- Arbitration can restrict the parties’ options: strikes and lockouts must stop, and the agreement is settled by an arbitration board unless the parties agree to final offer selection.
- The bill limits when decertification or displacement applications can take effect during arbitration. This could delay a challenge to the union’s status until after the first agreement is settled.