Summary#
Bill 83, titled in its text the Fairness in Labour Relations Act (Bargaining Units and Certification of Trade Unions), 2016, would amend Ontario’s Labour Relations Act, 1995. Its stated goal is to change how bargaining units are set and how trade unions are certified.
- A union could apply without describing the proposed bargaining unit. If it does not, the unit would include all the employer’s employees, subject to regulations.
- The Ontario Labour Relations Board would have to hold a hearing in key certification decisions. It would have to order a vote if the 40% membership threshold is met, or if employer interference helped prevent the union from reaching it. A union could not be certified without a vote.
- The bill changes the timing for holding a vote to no earlier than five and no later than 10 days after the application is filed.
- For construction-industry bargaining units, the Board could not limit a unit to a project, work site or shift. The bill also removes an exemption from some restrictions on strikes.
- The bill would put the burden of proof on complainants in specified Board matters and let affected parties appeal Board decisions to the Divisional Court.
What it means for you#
- Employees and unions: A union application without a proposed unit description would default to all of the employer’s employees, subject to regulations. A vote would be required before certification. In the general process, the Board would order one if at least 40% appear to be union members or if employer interference helped prevent the union from reaching that level.
- Employers: The Board would have to hold a hearing on whether to order a vote. If the Board finds employer interference helped prevent the union from reaching the 40% threshold, it would have to order a vote.
- Construction workers and employers: The Board could not confine a bargaining unit to a particular project, work site or shift. Removing the strike exemption does not itself ban strikes; the bill text does not set out the restrictions that would then apply.
- People bringing certain complaints or applications to the Board: They would bear the burden of proving their case in the specified proceedings.
- Parties affected by a Board decision: They could appeal it to the Divisional Court under court rules. This is not an appeal right for every person.
- Workers generally: The bill does not directly change wages, benefits or other employment terms.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The bill requires hearings in specified matters and allows appeals to court, but provides no estimate of the resulting Board or court costs, or of any added staffing.
- The bill does not state a new tax, fee, fine, benefit or appropriation.
What is unclear#
- The Labour Relations Act, 1995 itself was not supplied, so the bill’s changes could not be checked against the current Act. Its explanatory note describes some existing rules, but those descriptions could not be independently verified.
- The bill leaves some details to regulations, including rules affecting the default bargaining unit. Those regulations are not supplied.
- The bill does not set out the full procedures, timelines or appeal rules for the new hearings and appeals.
- The bill adds a definition of “coercion” and “intimidation” that includes repeated personal approaches, stalking and harassment, including threats. The supplied text does not explain how that definition would affect particular cases.
- The supplied heading calls this a 2017 bill, while the bill text gives its short title as a 2016 Act. Its legislative status is not stated. The text says it would come into force on Royal Assent.
Case for#
- A required vote would give employees a direct way to decide whether a union represents them, rather than allowing certification without a vote.
- Requiring a vote when employer interference blocked the 40% threshold could prevent that interference from stopping a vote.
- A Board hearing and a defined voting constituency could make certification decisions more transparent and give parties a chance to address the unit and voting group.
- Allowing appeals could provide a way for affected parties to challenge Board decisions in court.
Case against#
- A default unit of all employees could be too broad for some workplaces; the bill does not explain how regulations would address that concern.
- Putting the burden of proof on complainants and applicants could make it harder to establish a violation or obtain an order.
- Hearings and court appeals may add time and cost to labour disputes; the bill gives no estimate or detailed process.
- Removing the construction-industry strike exemption could limit access to strikes under the restrictions that would apply, but the supplied material does not show the full effect of those restrictions.