Central bargaining overhaul for schools

Summary#

Bill 92, the School Boards Collective Bargaining Amendment Act, 2017, amends Ontario’s School Boards Collective Bargaining Act, 2014 and makes related changes to other Acts. It was enacted as Chapter 3 of Ontario’s 2017 statutes. Its stated goal is to make central bargaining part of collective bargaining for school-board employees.

  • Before the change, the Act allowed central bargaining but did not require it. The amendments require every school board and every employee covered by the Act to have a bargaining agency for central bargaining.
  • The bill sets rules for designating employee bargaining agencies, including for non-teaching employees. The Minister makes designations by regulation; the Ontario Labour Relations Board (OLRB) can advise and, in some cases, order unions to join or form councils so employees are represented.
  • The Crown may help with local bargaining if asked. A school board may be required to report bargaining progress and provide information about an agreed settlement before ratification, but not details of discussions.
  • Agreements to continue collective agreements for two, three, four or five years are allowed in specified circumstances. The bargaining agencies must be authorized, and the Crown must approve the agreement.
  • The bill adds five days’ advance notice for certain changes to a strike or lock-out that would completely withdraw instruction or services or close one or more schools. It also says central terms prevail over conflicting local terms, with the OLRB able to decide disputes.

What it means for you#

  • School-board employees and unions: Employees must be represented by an employee bargaining agency for central bargaining. The bill sets rules for how non-teaching unions are grouped or designated. Employee agencies must not represent employees arbitrarily, discriminatorily or in bad faith.
  • School boards: Each must have an employer bargaining agency for central bargaining. An employer agency must act fairly and cooperate in good faith with the Crown. The Crown or the agency may require a board to report local bargaining progress, but cannot demand details of bargaining discussions under this provision.
  • School communities: The new notice rule applies when a change to a strike or lock-out would completely withdraw instruction or services or close schools. It does not prevent strikes or lock-outs.
  • Taxpayers and the public: The Education Relations Commission continues as an advisory commission; the bill does not create a new independent organization. It also brings trustees’ associations within the definition of “public sector” for salary disclosure.

Money#

No cost estimate is in the supplied material.

  • The bill allows the Commission’s members to receive remuneration and expenses set by the Lieutenant Governor in Council. No amounts are given.
  • The Minister, Ministry employees and OLRB may have additional administrative work. The material gives no staffing or cost estimate.
  • The bill does not set a new tax, fee or fine.

What is unclear#

  • Some provisions, including the central-bargaining changes, come into force only on a date set by proclamation. The supplied material does not give those dates.
  • The bill leaves important implementation details to regulations, including dates, information requirements and some OLRB procedures.
  • The OLRB need not hold a hearing on applications about employee bargaining agencies. The bill does not require the same opportunity for evidence and submissions in every case.
  • The supplied material does not explain how the new central-bargaining rules interact with all other existing programs or agreements. The current parent Acts were not supplied, so their present wording and the full current-law context could not be checked.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to ensure that all covered employees and boards have representatives at central bargaining, rather than making central bargaining optional.
  • Common central terms and a process to resolve conflicts between central and local terms could make bargaining rules clearer.
  • Advance notice of certain major strike or lock-out changes could give school communities warning of a full withdrawal of instruction or school closures.
  • Allowing approved extensions of collective agreements could give bargaining parties a way to continue existing agreements for a set period.

Case against#

  • Requiring central bargaining changes how bargaining is organized and may limit the role of local bargaining on matters covered by central terms.
  • The OLRB can order a union to join a council or establish one, and need not hold a hearing. The bill leaves some safeguards and procedures to later rules.
  • The Crown’s approval is required for central-table continuation agreements, and central terms prevail over conflicting local terms. This gives central bargaining and the Crown important roles in outcomes.
  • The bill requires new administrative work but provides no cost estimate or staffing details.

Votes

3 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 2017032301

    Passed89 members voted

    Third Reading of Bill 92

    FOR · 75AGAINST · 14

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    75For

    • Liberal53
    • PC22

    14Against

    • NDP14
  2. Division No. 2017030601

    Passed91 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 92

    FOR · 74AGAINST · 17

    74For

    • Liberal51
    • PC23

    17Against

    • NDP17
  3. Division No. 2017030201

    Passed90 members voted

    Government Notice of Motion Number 7 relating to allocation of time on Bill 92, An Act to amend the School Boards Collective Bargaining Act, 2014 and make related amendments to…

    FOR · 52AGAINST · 38

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    52For

    • Liberal52

    38Against

    • PC24
    • NDP14