Bill limits replacement workers in strikes

Summary#

Bill 90, the Anti-Scab Labour Act, 2023, would amend Ontario’s Labour Relations Act, 1995. Its stated goal is to restore restrictions on employers using replacement workers during strikes or lock-outs; the bill’s explanatory note says similar rules were repealed in 1995. The supplied material does not establish whether this bill became law.

  • Employers generally could not use specified replacement workers to do striking or locked-out employees’ work. The rules apply to a lock-out or a lawful strike approved by at least 60% of those voting, with the required timing and voting process.
  • Limited exceptions would allow replacement workers to do only the work needed for listed care, shelter, child-protection, custody, emergency and first-aid services, or to prevent danger to life, health or safety, serious damage to machinery, equipment or premises, or serious environmental damage.
  • Employers would have to notify the union about proposed exception-related replacement work. The union could offer willing and able bargaining-unit employees to do it instead. The Ontario Labour Relations Board could decide whether exceptions apply and give directions.
  • The bill sets rules for reinstating striking or locked-out employees when they return, and lets a union tender payments to continue employees’ non-pension benefits during a lawful strike or lock-out.
  • The bill would take effect on Royal Assent. It creates no general new service for the public.

What it means for you#

  • Employers and unions: The restrictions would apply during a lock-out or a qualifying lawful strike. They would restrict using newly hired or engaged people for the affected work, as well as certain workers from other locations, transferred workers and people supplied by another employer. The bill also bars requiring an employee at the affected location to do striking or locked-out employees’ work without that employee’s agreement.
  • Employers and unions: The exceptions cover secure custody or detention; specified residential care and related support; emergency shelters and crisis intervention for specified groups, including victims of violence; emergency child-protection investigations; emergency dispatch, ambulance and first-aid services; and work needed to prevent the listed dangers or damage. Use must be limited to what is necessary. In an emergency, an employer could use a replacement worker temporarily while giving notice and checking whether the union consents to using willing and able bargaining-unit employees.
  • Employees: Employers could not punish, threaten or discriminate against a person for refusing to do strike or lock-out work. If there is no agreement on reinstatement, employees generally return to their former positions and may displace others doing their work, subject to the bill’s seniority and work-availability rules.
  • Employees and unions: A union could pay enough to continue non-pension benefits, including insurance coverage. The employer or other recipient would have to accept the payment and take steps to continue coverage. The bill also bars cancelling or denying specified benefits in the circumstances it describes.
  • The public: The bill does not directly change taxes, create a public benefit, or give the public a new application or complaint process.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill provides no estimate of costs for employers, unions, or the Labour Relations Board.
  • A union could tender payments to continue non-pension benefits during a lawful strike or lock-out; the bill does not estimate those payments or say how often they might be made.

What is unclear#

  • The explanatory note says the bill restores rules that were later repealed, but the current Labour Relations Act was not supplied. I could not verify the current law or the exact change against it.
  • The bill does not define key terms such as “serious environmental damage” or “serious deterioration” of machinery, equipment or premises. It also refers to a definition elsewhere in the Act that is not included in the supplied text.
  • The text does not set out a detailed application or decision process for the Board, or a deadline for its decisions. It allows the Board to defer applications.
  • No publicly available information on costs, staffing needs or how the rules would interact with other programs is included in the supplied material.
  • The supplied text does not establish whether the bill passed. It says the changes would start on Royal Assent.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to limit employers’ ability to replace workers during a strike or lock-out, which could preserve workers’ ability to use a strike as part of collective bargaining.
  • The limits are paired with exceptions for listed services and serious risks, rather than an absolute ban on replacement workers.
  • Notice to the union and the option to use willing and able bargaining-unit employees could give those employees priority for necessary work.
  • Reinstatement and benefit-continuation rules could reduce some employment and insurance uncertainty during and after a work stoppage.

Case against#

  • Restrictions on replacement workers could make it harder for an employer to keep some operations running during a strike or lock-out. The bill does not quantify the effect.
  • Terms such as “danger” and “serious environmental damage” are not defined in the supplied text. Disagreement over whether an exception applies could require a Board decision.
  • Notice, consent and possible Board proceedings could add steps during a work stoppage. The text does not set decision deadlines.
  • The bill creates duties for employers and unions, but the supplied material gives no estimate of compliance, benefit or Board costs.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 2023112701

    Defeated88 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 90

    AGAINST · 58FOR · 30

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    58Against

    • PC56
    • Independent2

    30For

    • NDP22
    • Liberal6
    • Green1
    • Independent1