Summary#
Bill 124, the Rental Fairness Act, 2017, was enacted as Chapter 13 of Ontario’s 2017 statutes. It amends the Residential Tenancies Act, 2006. Its stated goal is rental fairness; that is a goal, not a guaranteed result.
- It removed rent-control exemptions for certain units that were previously exempt, while setting special rules for some rent-increase notices already given.
- It added rules for prescribed classes of tenancy agreements, including a tenant’s ability in certain cases to withhold up to one month’s rent or end a fixed-term or yearly tenancy.
- It added protections and compensation rules for tenants whose landlord gives notice to take back a unit for personal use.
- It exempted certain supported-living programs from the Act if they meet program and written-agreement requirements.
- It changed above-guideline rent increases: landlords can no longer apply on the basis of higher utility costs, and elevator-related orders and unfinished work can affect applications.
What it means for you#
- Tenants in formerly exempt units: The removed exemptions covered some units first occupied after June 17, 1998; units not previously rented since July 29, 1975; and units in buildings or communities with no residential occupancy before November 1, 1991. These units became subject to the rent guideline unless another exemption applies. The bill set transition rules for earlier rent-increase notices; for example, some increases above the guideline had to be reduced and excess rent refunded.
- Tenants and landlords: For tenancy classes and dates set by regulation, agreements must use a prescribed form and meet prescribed requirements. If a landlord does not provide a compliant proposed agreement within 21 days after a tenant’s written demand, the tenant may withhold rent that comes due, up to one month’s rent. The landlord can require that withheld rent to be repaid if the landlord complies within 30 days after the first rent payment was withheld.
- Tenants in those prescribed classes: After making that demand, a tenant may end a yearly or fixed-term tenancy in specified circumstances, with at least 60 days’ notice effective on the last day of a rental period.
- Tenants facing a personal-use eviction: The landlord must be an individual and the unit must be owned at least partly by an individual. The person who needs the unit must intend to live there for at least one year. The landlord must pay one month’s rent or offer another unit the tenant accepts. The bill also added a presumption of bad faith if, within the specified period, the landlord advertises the unit for rent or sale, rents it to someone else, demolishes it, or takes steps to convert it to another use.
- Residents in supported-living programs: The Act does not apply if the program meets the bill’s conditions, including a maximum intended stay of four years, specified support services, and government or registered-charity funding or provision. A written agreement must set out key terms, charges, and a dispute process. An existing tenancy covered by the Act must first be ended under that Act.
- Landlords: Above-guideline applications can still be based on extraordinary municipal tax or charge increases and eligible capital expenditures, but not utility-cost increases. The bill also prohibits certain charges against former tenants and rent demands for periods after the tenant has left.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The bill requires compensation of one month’s rent or an acceptable alternative unit for a personal-use termination.
- It requires refunds in some rent-increase transition cases. No overall amount is given.
- Tenants may withhold no more than one month’s rent over a non-compliant tenancy agreement, subject to the repayment rules.
What is unclear#
- The supplied material does not give the regulations setting tenancy classes, start dates, agreement forms, or additional requirements.
- The bill does not define some key terms, including “therapeutic services” and services supporting employment or life-skills development.
- It does not provide estimates for staffing, administration, enforcement, or the refunds and compensation that may be required.
- The materials describe amendments, not the full current Residential Tenancies Act. I cannot verify the Act’s current text or later changes against them.
- Several provisions were to start on dates set by proclamation, but the supplied material does not give those dates.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to extend rent-guideline protections to units that had been exempt, while protecting some rent increases already notified before the change.
- Requiring a one-year personal-use intention, compensation, and a good-faith affidavit could make personal-use evictions more accountable.
- A prescribed agreement could give tenants clearer terms, and the supported-living exemption could allow programs to pair housing with services while requiring written terms and a dispute process.
Case against#
- The supported-living exemption removes residents from the Act’s tenancy protections. The bill sets agreement requirements but does not specify a standard level of service or what happens if a resident loses program access.
- Tenancy-form rules depend on regulations, so the bill itself does not establish which tenancies are covered or when.
- The transition rules and enforcement provisions are detailed, but the material provides no estimate of their administrative cost or how they will be carried out.