Rental cap bill would curb rent hikes

Summary#

Bill 170, the Keeping People Housed Act, 2024, would amend Ontario’s Residential Tenancies Act, 2006, the City of Toronto Act, 2006 and the Municipal Act, 2001. Its stated purpose is to implement measures respecting rental accommodation. The bill would change rent rules and create new requirements for landlords, municipalities and the Landlord and Tenant Board.

  • It would repeal the exemption in section 6.1 of the Residential Tenancies Act from rent-control provisions for the units described there.
  • It would limit the lawful rent for a new tenant, generally linking it to the last lawful rent for the unit. Tenants could apply to the Board to determine the lawful rent and, if they were overcharged, the Board would have to order a rebate.
  • Landlords ending a tenancy for repairs or renovations would have to provide required approvals and an engineer’s statement that vacant possession is necessary. They would also have to offer the tenant an acceptable rental unit during the work or pay compensation under the bill’s formula.
  • The Board would have to maintain a rent registry. Landlords would have to file information about each covered unit and report rent changes; some information, including the address and rent, would be public.
  • For demolitions or conversions that would remove six or more rental units, municipalities could not approve the project unless all the units have rents above the mid-range or the applicant replaces the units and provides an approved tenant relocation and assistance plan.
  • The Minister would appoint a temporary Rental Task Force to study above-guideline rent increases and report. The Minister would have to tell the Assembly which recommendations the Minister recommends the government implement; the bill does not require the government to adopt them.

What it means for you#

  • Tenants: If your unit is covered by section 6.1’s exemption, the bill would remove that exemption. For a new tenancy, the lawful rent would generally be tied to the previous lawful rent, with different calculations for units not rented in the last 12 months and an exception for units never previously rented. The rule is subject to section 111 of the Act.
  • Tenants facing repairs or renovations: The landlord would have to provide the required approvals and engineer’s statement with the termination notice, then offer you another acceptable unit for the work period or pay compensation. The compensation is based on the cost of a comparable unit, subject to the bill’s limits.
  • Tenants and prospective tenants: You could access registry information about a particular unit in the circumstances listed in the bill. A tenant could challenge the accuracy of their unit’s information within 60 days of receiving a copy. The public could see each unit’s address and rent, rent-change dates, and the landlord’s name and contact information, or an Ontario agent’s details.
  • Landlords: You would have to file a statement within 30 days of entering a lease, report rent changes within 30 days after they take effect, and give the tenant copies. Failure to file or filing false information would be an offence. The bill does not state the penalty amount.
  • Landlords seeking to demolish or convert rental buildings: Where six or more units would be lost, approval would require either rents above the mid-range or replacement units and a relocation plan meeting the bill’s conditions.
  • Municipalities and the Board: Municipalities would face limits on approving qualifying demolitions or conversions. The Board would have to maintain the registry and carry out the rent-related duties described above.

Money#

No cost estimate is included in the supplied material.

  • The Board would have to establish and maintain the registry, and the Minister would have to appoint and support the Rental Task Force; no public cost or staffing estimate is given.
  • Landlords would have new filing and reporting duties. The bill does not estimate their costs.
  • Applicants choosing the replacement option for a qualifying demolition or conversion would have to provide replacement units and tenant assistance. No cost estimate is given.
  • A landlord required to compensate a tenant for repairs or renovations would pay according to the bill’s formula.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the amended Acts, so the exact scope of the section 6.1 exemption and how these changes fit with current law could not be verified.
  • The bill does not define “mid-range rents,” “similar” rents, or “comparable” rental units. It also leaves some registry details to future rules.
  • It does not set out the full process for Board decisions, beyond the stated applications and deadlines, or how the Board will verify and correct registry information.
  • The bill gives a general start rule of four months after Royal Assent, with one provision starting later. The supplied material does not say whether the bill passed or when it might receive Royal Assent.

Case for#

  • Tying a new tenant’s lawful rent to the unit’s previous lawful rent could limit rent increases when a tenant changes.
  • Requiring approvals and an engineer’s statement could help establish whether repairs or renovations genuinely require vacant possession.
  • Replacement units, similar rents and relocation assistance could reduce the loss and disruption for tenants affected by large demolitions or conversions.
  • A public registry could give tenants and prospective tenants information about rents and landlords.

Case against#

  • The bill does not define key terms used in the municipal approval rules and compensation formula, which could make their application uncertain.
  • The registry would make unit addresses, rents and landlord contact details public. The bill does not describe further limits on access to that public information.
  • New filing duties, registry operations and replacement-unit requirements could impose costs, but the bill provides no estimates.
  • The Task Force would make recommendations, but the bill does not require the government to adopt them.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 2024041001

    Defeated102 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 170

    AGAINST · 66FOR · 36

    66Against

    • PC66

    36For

    • NDP25
    • Liberal7
    • Green2
    • Independent2