Summary#
Bill 127, the Stronger, Healthier Ontario Act (Budget Measures), 2017, was enacted as a law that amends many Ontario Acts, creates the Ontario Loan Act, 2017, and replaces three accounting Acts with the Chartered Professional Accountants of Ontario Act, 2017. Its stated goal is to carry out measures in the 2017 Ontario Budget; that goal does not guarantee any particular result. Some changes started later or require a proclamation, and the supplied material does not say whether all such provisions have since taken effect.
- The City of Toronto and certain other municipalities may create taxes on vacant residential units. Municipalities may also tax purchases of transient accommodation, such as short-term stays, and may require some businesses to collect the tax.
- The law changes worker compensation, pension rules, and nursing authority: it provides WSIB benefits for qualifying chronic or traumatic mental stress, permits registered nurses to prescribe drugs designated by regulation, and adds rules for pension variable-benefit accounts.
- It creates the Mining and Lands Tribunal to take over the Mining and Lands Commissioner’s functions. It also combines Ontario’s three accounting bodies into Chartered Professional Accountants of Ontario, which regulates members and firms.
- It expands some enforcement and liability powers, including tobacco-related penalties, recovery of fire-related losses, and new tools for collecting certain debts on behalf of other public bodies.
- Other changes affect tax rules, financial and securities regulation, public-record disclosure, and municipal property assessment. The Act also authorizes Ontario to borrow up to $6 billion.
- The Act does not itself impose a tax on foreign buyers of land. It creates an exception that could allow a bill proposing such a tax to proceed without the usual referendum requirement.
What it means for you#
- Municipal taxpayers, property owners and accommodation businesses: A municipality may choose to tax vacant homes or transient accommodation, but the tax is not automatic. The municipality must set rules in a by-law, and regulations may add conditions. Businesses may have to collect an accommodation tax if a by-law requires it.
- Workers and employers: A worker may qualify for WSIB benefits for chronic or traumatic mental stress arising from work. The law excludes stress caused by employer decisions or actions about employment, including changing duties or conditions, discipline, or termination. The WSIB also gains authority to set policies on benefit interpretation and evidence.
- Registered nurses and patients: Registered nurses may prescribe only drugs designated in regulations, and remain subject to conditions on their registration. The bill does not itself list those drugs.
- Pension plan members and spouses: The law sets rules for dividing variable-benefit accounts after relationship breakdown and paying benefits after a retired member’s death. It also allows regulations to create conditional exemptions for specified U.S. Steel pension plans, after an agreement and the Superintendent’s approval.
- Accountants and accounting firms: The three predecessor bodies are amalgamated into CPA Ontario. Members and registered firms transfer to the new organization, which regulates professional conduct and qualifications.
- People seeking government records: A public institution may refuse to disclose records if disclosure could reasonably be expected to harm relations with a defined Aboriginal community or reveal information received from one in confidence. This is a power to refuse, not a ban on disclosure.
- Taxpayers generally: Ontario receives authority to borrow up to $6 billion. The bill also changes some tax calculations and refund rules; it does not establish a foreign-buyer land tax.
Money#
The bill authorizes up to $6 billion in Ontario borrowing, but the available material gives no overall cost estimate.
- Borrowing is authorized to meet Ontario obligations or payments; the $6 billion is a ceiling, not a statement that the full amount will be borrowed.
- New municipal taxes could raise revenue if municipalities adopt them. The bill does not set the resulting tax rates or predict revenue.
- The law requires some employers, institutions, or agencies to provide information, staff, or collection services in specified circumstances, but no cost estimates are provided.
- It changes benefit amounts and eligibility rules, but the material gives no estimate of their total cost.
- Some tobacco and other offences carry fines or penalties. No expected revenue is provided.
What is unclear#
- Which municipalities will be designated for vacant-unit taxes, and what definitions, exemptions, rates, and dispute processes will apply, depend on regulations and local by-laws.
- Several provisions start only on a proclaimed date. The supplied material does not establish which of those provisions have since started.
- The materials do not give the cost of implementing the new powers, staffing, benefit changes, or debt-collection services.
- The Act creates an exception related to a possible foreign-buyer tax, but does not set out that tax’s rate, scope, or start date because it does not impose the tax.
- For some changes, including designated drugs nurses may prescribe and the additional amount deducted from pharmacy payments, key details are left to regulations.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to give municipalities more choices to raise revenue and address vacant homes or visitor accommodation, while allowing local rules to differ.
- Expanding WSIB coverage to qualifying work-related mental stress could provide benefits to workers whose injuries were not covered under the previous rules.
- Consolidating accounting bodies and replacing the Mining and Lands Commissioner’s office with a tribunal could bring related regulatory or hearing functions under one structure.
- Stronger collection and enforcement tools could help public bodies collect amounts owed and recover costs from people responsible for fires or tobacco-law offences.
Case against#
- The bill grants many powers while leaving important details to regulations, ministerial decisions, or local by-laws; costs and practical effects may therefore be hard to assess from the Act alone.
- Municipal taxes could add costs for some property owners and accommodation businesses, and collection duties could create work for businesses.
- Broader recovery powers and new enforcement rules may have serious effects on individuals or businesses, while the bill does not provide a single common process or estimate of how often they will be used.
- The WSIB gains authority to set policies on evidence and benefit decisions. The bill does not specify those policies, so their effect on claims is unclear.
- Some changes are conditional or delayed, including the possible pension exemptions and provisions requiring proclamation, making their actual reach uncertain.