Summary#
The Restoring Trust, Transparency and Accountability Act, 2018 is an omnibus law: it amends many existing Ontario laws and creates two short-lived or time-limited Acts. Its stated goal is to restore trust, transparency and accountability; that is a goal, not a guaranteed result. The bill received Royal Assent and became Chapter 17 of Ontario’s 2018 statutes, but some changes require a later proclamation to start.
- Rent rules: The Residential Tenancies Act exempts certain newly occupied buildings and some newly created units in houses from specified rent rules, including the rent-increase guideline. The exemption has conditions, and a landlord must prove that it applies.
- Public oversight: The Auditor General, Ombudsman and other Assembly officers are appointed directly by the Assembly under new procedures. Environmental and French-language services are reorganized, and the Ombudsman gains authority to investigate certain services for children and young people.
- Government and transportation: Metrolinx’s regional transportation area expands. Its transportation plan needs ministerial approval, and the Minister can amend it. The law also provides for winding up Ontario Place Corporation and transferring its assets, liabilities, rights and obligations to the Crown or a Crown agency; a separate repeal and dissolution law starts by proclamation.
- Money and taxes: The law cancels a scheduled beer-tax increase, creates a low-income tax credit of up to $850 subject to a formula, and authorizes interim spending and borrowing. It also ends the small-business transition support payments.
- Other rules: It adds financial-benchmark regulation powers and bans false information and improper influence in setting benchmarks. It also changes construction payment and adjudication rules, election contribution rules, and protections for volunteer firefighters.
What it means for you#
- Renters and landlords: Some units meeting the law’s conditions are exempt from named rent rules, including limits linked to the guideline. Existing tenancies under agreements made on or before November 15, 2018 are not covered by the new exemption, but later tenancies may be. This does not remove every rule in the Residential Tenancies Act.
- Low-income taxpayers: Eligible Ontario residents may claim a credit of up to $850, reduced by income under the law’s formula. The maximum is not a guaranteed payment.
- Beer purchasers and Legion branches: The scheduled November 2018 beer-tax increase is removed. Ontario Royal Canadian Legion branches’ land used and occupied as memorial homes, clubhouses or athletic grounds is exempted from taxation.
- Volunteer firefighters: Employers and firefighters’ associations are barred from specified employment or disciplinary actions because a firefighter has worked, is working or intends to work as a volunteer firefighter.
- Children and young people in care: Children’s aid societies and residential licensees must explain how to contact the Ombudsman, allow private contact without delay, and provide private access without unreasonable delay. The Ombudsman may investigate specified services. The Provincial Advocate’s office is wound down, with some ongoing matters referred to the Ombudsman.
- People using transit in the expanded region: Metrolinx must plan for an integrated transit network and follow relevant provincial direction. The bill does not make every local transit system part of a unified fare system.
- Other affected groups: Benchmark administrators, contributors and users may have to follow future rules made by regulation. Ontario Place Corporation’s assets and obligations are transferred as provided by the winding-up and dissolution provisions.
Money#
The law authorizes interim spending of up to $110.8 billion for public-service expenses, $4.2 billion for investments and $190 million for Legislative Office expenses for 2019–20; these are spending limits pending the regular supply vote, not estimates of the bill’s added cost.
- It also authorizes up to $42.404 million in supplementary interim spending for Legislative Offices for 2018–19, and borrowing of up to $1.9 billion. Borrowing authority is not itself a direction to spend that amount.
- The IESO must pay certain amounts arising from a specified terminated procurement contract only from money appropriated for that purpose. No amount is set in this bill.
- The law allows fees for family-law mediation services under agreements with the Attorney General. The fees must be published; the bill sets no amounts.
- No overall cost estimate is provided. Staffing and implementation costs are not quantified.
What is unclear#
- The bill leaves many details to future regulations, including benchmark requirements and some pension rules.
- The bill does not specify the fees, eligibility process or service levels for family-law mediation.
- The effect of the rent exemptions depends on the facts of each unit and tenancy; the bill does not provide a process beyond the landlord’s burden to prove eligibility.
- The text allows some changes to start by proclamation, but does not set dates for all of them. The Pay Transparency Act’s start date is postponed to a day to be named.
- The supplied material does not include the full parent Acts, so I could not verify every change against the law as it stood before this Act.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the rent exemption is that it distinguishes certain new or newly created units from existing rental homes, while preserving the exemption for a tenancy already agreed to by the cutoff date.
- Moving children’s service investigations to the Ombudsman gives children in care a route to raise concerns and requires providers to support private contact.
- New benchmark rules and bans on false information or improper influence could help address risks in financial benchmarks used in contracts and investments.
- Direct Assembly appointments and cross-party selection rules for several officers could strengthen their separation from the executive government.
Case against#
- Renters in qualifying units may lose protections against certain rent increases and other listed rent rules. The law does not explain how this change will affect rents.
- The Assembly appointment rules permit an exception by unanimous consent, while the bill does not require a public selection process. The arrangements may not ensure public scrutiny in every appointment.
- Metrolinx must follow provincial directions, and a government representative may participate in all board meetings, including closed meetings. This could reduce the board’s independence in planning.
- The bill gives the Speaker authority to authorize certain Legislative Protective Service officers to carry weapons, including firearms, and gives them police-officer powers in the legislative precinct. The text leaves some limits to guidelines and regulations.