Bills cut 25% for regulated-rate consumers

Summary#

Bill 132, the Fair Hydro Act, 2017, was enacted as Ontario law. It creates the Ontario Fair Hydro Plan Act, 2017 and amends the Electricity Act, 1998 and the Ontario Energy Board Act, 1998. Its stated goal is to allocate clean-energy costs and benefits fairly among present and future electricity consumers.

  • For the first adjustment period, the Ontario Energy Board had to set rates so a typical regulated-rate consumer’s total invoice was 25% lower than under the bill’s comparison method. Other specified consumers received adjustments set under regulations; the 25% rule does not automatically apply to them.
  • The law creates a financing system: the Independent Electricity System Operator (IESO) records certain costs in a variance account, and can transfer the right to recover those amounts to financing entities.
  • Ontario Power Generation Inc. (OPG) is the Financial Services Manager unless it cannot or will not serve. It must prepare a Financing Plan; financing entities may incur funding obligations under that plan.
  • Specified consumers must pay a “clean energy adjustment” on their electricity bills. Vendors must invoice and collect it, and the IESO must pass the money to investment-interest owners.
  • The law continues the Ontario Electricity Support Program and creates distribution-rate protection for certain residential consumers and a delivery credit for eligible on-reserve consumers. These supports are funded from money appropriated by the Legislature, subject to the funding rules in the Act.
  • The Act also permits the province to guarantee or indemnify certain financing obligations, but does not require it to do so.

What it means for you#

  • Electricity consumers: If you are a specified consumer—which includes many households, small-use accounts and qualifying farms—the law requires a clean energy adjustment on your bill. The Act treats the invoiced amount as a separate debt; it is generally irrevocable, except for clerical, typographical or calculation errors.
  • Regulated-rate consumers: Your rate for the first adjustment period was set to produce a total invoice 25% below the comparison invoice described in the Act. This is a bill reduction at that time, not a promise that electricity costs disappear.
  • Other consumers: You may have received a different adjustment. The amount and method depend on regulations and Ontario Energy Board determinations.
  • People receiving electricity support: The law continues the Ontario Electricity Support Program. It also allows personal information to be shared for administration: the Ministry of Community and Social Services may use information from Ontario Works and disability-support records to identify and contact people who may qualify.
  • Eligible residential and on-reserve consumers: The law provides for distribution-rate protection and delivery credits. Eligibility, start dates and amounts depend on regulations.
  • Vendors, the IESO and OPG: They have duties to invoice, collect, report, transfer funds, keep records or manage financing. This is mainly a financing and administrative system, not a new independent agency or a new general front-line service.

Money#

No cost estimate for the law is in the supplied material.

  • The law shifts some clean-energy costs and financing costs across time, with specified consumers paying the clean energy adjustment. Recovery of the IESO’s recorded balance from consumers cannot begin before May 1, 2021.
  • Legislature-approved money is to fund the Ontario Electricity Support Program after its specified variance-account funding is no longer sufficient, as well as the new distribution-rate protection and on-reserve delivery credits.
  • OPG may charge approved fees for prescribed work and may recover costs and expenditures; the regulations may also allow it to earn a return.
  • The province may guarantee or indemnify certain obligations, subject to approval and limits set by the Lieutenant Governor in Council. This is an authority, not a requirement.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the parent Acts, so I could not verify how the amendments compare with the full laws in force at the time.
  • Many practical details—including adjustment methods, support eligibility, credit amounts and start dates—are left to regulations.
  • The Act does not give a cost estimate, the expected total financing obligations, or the likely size of any provincial guarantee or indemnity.
  • The Act does not set out a full application, review or appeal process for the new protections and credits.
  • The meaning of “clean energy benefits” depends partly on estimates and methods chosen by officials; the Act does not fix all those methods in its text.

Case for#

  • The law appears intended to address the burden of electricity costs falling heavily on current consumers while electricity investments may benefit consumers for years. Spreading costs over time could be seen as matching payments to the period when benefits are received.
  • The initial rate adjustment gives regulated-rate consumers a defined reduction for the specified period.
  • The law provides for targeted support for electricity costs, including assistance for low-income consumers and eligible on-reserve consumers.
  • A Financing Plan and Ontario Energy Board approval of certain fees provide some defined roles and checks within the financing system.

Case against#

  • One concern is that lowering bills now does not remove the underlying costs: the law creates a charge on future bills and financing obligations that may last for decades.
  • The clean energy adjustment is generally payable even if estimates used to calculate it were wrong or later corrected. This limits consumers’ ability to challenge the billed amount, apart from specified errors.
  • Important rules are left to regulations, making the full cost and practical effects hard to assess from the Act alone.
  • The law gives investment-interest owners strong property and recovery rights, including priority over certain other claims. A possible trade-off is less flexibility to change the payment arrangement once financing obligations have been incurred.

Votes

4 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 2017053102

    Passed94 members voted

    Third Reading of Bill 132

    FOR · 53AGAINST · 41

    53For

    • Liberal53

    41Against

    • PC26
    • NDP14
    • Independent1
  2. Division No. 2017051801

    Passed90 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 132

    FOR · 52AGAINST · 38

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    52For

    • Liberal52

    38Against

    • PC25
    • NDP13
  3. Division No. 2017051701

    Passed97 members voted

    Government Notice of Motion Number 30 for allocation of time on Bill 132, An Act to enact the Ontario Fair Hydro Plan Act, 2017 and to make amendments to the…

    FOR · 53AGAINST · 44

    53For

    • Liberal53

    44Against

    • PC28
    • NDP16
  4. Division No. 2017051702

    Passed97 members voted

    Ordered, That, pursuant to Standing Order 47 and notwithstanding any other Standing Order or Special Order of the House relating to Bill 132, An Act to enact the Ontario Fair…

    FOR · 53AGAINST · 44

    53For

    • Liberal53

    44Against

    • PC28
    • NDP16