Summary#
Bill 197, the Affordable Electricity Act, 2018, would create a new Act; it does not directly amend an existing Act. It would put duties on Ontario’s Minister of Energy, with the stated goal of giving residents and small businesses access to clean electricity at the lowest possible cost.
- The Minister must ensure electricity rules and policies give the highest priority to lowering customer costs, including by making publicly owned water- and nuclear-powered stations as useful as possible, requiring competitive bids from all potential suppliers, and making pricing decisions and utility-supplier payments public.
- The Minister must end preferential treatment for new wind and solar projects, end existing subsidies for those projects at the earliest possible opportunity, and cancel all conservation program subsidies paid by the Independent Electricity System Operator (IESO).
- The Minister must set procedures for an efficiently maintained grid, lower operating and maintenance costs to levels comparable with the most cost-effective private operations, disclose grid costs, pass savings to customers, remove restrictions on suppliers using the grid to serve willing customers, and charge for grid use in proportion to the service’s actual cost.
- The bill would prohibit measures that lower electricity prices by borrowing money that must be repaid later. It would require bills to itemize deferred costs—including those linked to the Ontario Fair Hydro Plan Act, 2017 and other laws or policies—and sunk-cost repayments, with the relevant law and year identified.
- Ontario-generated surplus electricity must be offered first to Ontario customers, at no more than the lowest rate offered to customers in neighbouring provinces or U.S. states. The Minister must also modify metering, study ways to improve customers’ access to system savings, and implement related policy and rule changes.
What it means for you#
- Residents and small businesses: The Minister would have a broad duty to ensure access to clean electricity at the lowest possible cost. The bill does not guarantee a particular bill reduction or create a process for an individual customer to claim one.
- Electricity customers: Bills would have to show specified deferred costs and sunk-cost repayments. The Minister would also have to ensure customers receive the full benefit of grid-management savings.
- Electricity suppliers and utilities: They would be affected by competitive bidding, public disclosure of pricing arrangements and payments, and new requirements for grid access and charges.
- Wind and solar project operators, and conservation program recipients: Their subsidies or preferential treatment would be ended as described in the bill. Existing wind and solar subsidies would end at the earliest possible opportunity, not necessarily immediately.
- The public: The bill directs the Minister to make electricity pricing decisions and specified utility-supplier arrangements open to public scrutiny.
Money#
No publicly available information on the bill’s total public cost, savings, or effect on electricity bills.
- The Minister would have to arrange metering changes, a study, and changes to rules and policies, but the bill gives no cost estimate, staffing level, or funding source.
- Ending subsidies could reduce payments, but the amount and timing are not stated.
- The bill does not set a new tax, fee, or fine.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not define “clean electricity,” “lowest possible cost,” or “maximum advantage.”
- It does not explain how bids would be compared, how “surplus” electricity would be identified, or how the required neighbouring-region price would be determined.
- It does not set out how or when wind and solar subsidies would end, or identify which conservation subsidies would be cancelled.
- It does not specify how grid costs would be compared with private operations, or how savings would be calculated and passed to customers.
- The supplied material does not show how these duties would interact with current electricity rules and programs, or whether Bill 197 passed. The text says the Act would start on Royal Assent and sets a December 31, 2018 deadline.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to make lowering customer costs the main priority in electricity rules and policies.
- Competitive bids, public pricing information, and disclosure of grid costs could make electricity spending easier to scrutinize.
- Requiring savings from more efficient grid management to reach customers could connect lower operating costs to customer bills.
- Giving Ontario customers first access to surplus power could help them benefit from electricity produced in the province.
Case against#
- One concern is that the bill gives the Minister wide duties but leaves key terms and the methods for carrying them out undefined.
- Ending wind and solar subsidies and conservation subsidies could reduce support for those projects and programs; the bill does not assess the effects.
- The bill prioritizes lowering costs but does not explain how that priority should be balanced with its goal of access to clean electricity.
- The bill sets ambitious grid and metering requirements without stating their cost, funding, or how the required changes would be measured.