Summary#
Bill 72, the St. James Town Act (Residential Tenancies Amendments), 2021, would amend Ontario’s Residential Tenancies Act, 2006. It aims to set aside rent money for major repairs and strengthen some tenant hearing and rent-abatement rules; those goals are not guaranteed results.
- Landlords of complexes with 10 or more rental units would have to keep an account at a financial institution and deposit a prescribed share of rent into it within 30 days.
- Money in that account could be used only for major repairs to units or shared areas and facilities available to residents. Routine maintenance, and repairs needed because the landlord failed to do routine maintenance, would not count as major repairs.
- For a tenant’s application under section 29, the Landlord and Tenant Board would have to hold a written hearing if the tenant asks, unless the landlord shows a good reason to hear oral evidence or submissions. The Board would also have to address written hearings in its rules.
- In specified cases, the Board would have to order a rent abatement (a reduction or repayment of rent). The amount would depend on the case and any applicable regulations.
- The bill would limit how certain expenses are treated under section 126 for complexes with 10 or more units: they would count only to the extent they exceed the account balance. The supplied text does not include that section’s full context.
- The account and abatement rules would not apply to rental units described in subsection 7(1). The bill’s start date would be Royal Assent, except the account rule would start three months later.
What it means for you#
- Tenants: If you make an application under section 29, you could request a written hearing. The landlord could still seek an oral hearing by showing the Board a good reason.
- Tenants: The Board would have to order an abatement if it finds the specified breaches or activities occurred. For breaches of the landlord’s duties under section 20(1) or section 161, the abatement would take account of severity and duration, and would be ordered regardless of how responsible the landlord was. For the activities listed in section 29(1), paragraphs 2 to 5, it would take account of their impact and duration.
- Landlords of 10-or-more-unit complexes: You would have to set up and maintain the account, deposit the prescribed share of rent on time, and use the money only for qualifying major repairs.
- Landlords: The bill would not require the account to pay for routine maintenance or repairs made necessary by a failure to do routine maintenance. It also would not create a general rent reduction for tenants.
- Landlords and tenants: The bill does not create an application or review process for the repair account. I could not verify how these changes compare with current law because the parent Act was not supplied.
Money#
No publicly available information on the bill’s total public or private costs.
- Landlords would have to set aside a prescribed percentage of rent, but the bill does not state the percentage.
- The account would hold money for qualifying repairs; the bill does not estimate repair costs or say how much would be deposited.
- The Board would have to address written hearings in its rules. No staffing or implementation cost is given.
- For certain expenses under section 126(1)(2), the bill would allow only the amount above the account balance to count for complexes with 10 or more units. The full effect cannot be verified from the supplied text.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not state the prescribed rent percentage or explain how it would be set.
- The text does not explain how account balances would be checked, or what happens if a landlord does not deposit or properly use the money.
- The bill refers to rental units in subsection 7(1), but the supplied text omits the list describing those units. It is unclear who would be exempt from the account and abatement rules.
- The bill refers to regulated minimum abatement amounts, but does not provide them. The rules for deciding amounts are not fully set out here.
- The supplied text does not include the current version of the Residential Tenancies Act. I could not verify which expenses section 126(1)(2) covers or the full current rules being changed.
Case for#
- A separate account could help ensure that a share of rent is available for major repairs rather than other uses.
- Excluding repairs caused by neglected routine maintenance could discourage landlords from treating neglected upkeep as a major repair.
- Written hearings at a tenant’s request could make some Board proceedings easier to take part in, while allowing oral evidence where the landlord shows a good reason.
- Required abatements could give tenants a remedy when the Board finds specified breaches or activities.
Case against#
- The bill leaves the rent percentage and key abatement details to regulations or further rules, so important parts of its effect are not set out in the text.
- It does not explain how compliance with the account rules would be monitored or enforced.
- Mandatory abatements regardless of how responsible a landlord was could produce results that do not reflect the landlord’s degree of control over a breach.
- A written hearing may not suit every case involving disputed evidence, though the bill allows an oral hearing where the landlord shows a good reason.