Gas invoices must reveal cap-and-trade costs

Summary#

Bill 146, the Transparency in Gas Pricing Act, 2017, would amend the Ontario Energy Board Act, 1998. Its stated goal is to make certain gas-distribution costs more visible on consumer invoices.

  • Gas distributors that invoice consumers for gas distribution services would have to show, clearly and prominently, a separate amount reasonably attributable to costs of meeting obligations under Ontario’s cap-and-trade law or doing things that law authorizes.
  • Those costs include labour, disbursements and expenses, and may include costs related to emission allowances and credits.
  • The bill would allow regulations to set further invoice requirements, including different requirements for different circumstances.
  • An error or omission on an invoice would not, by itself, invalidate a proceeding to recover the amount payable.

What it means for you#

  • Gas consumers: Your invoice would have to separately display the covered costs. The bill does not itself add a fee or change the amount of those costs; it requires disclosure.
  • Gas distributors: They would have to calculate and display the required amount. The bill does not set a calculation method or require them to use a particular invoice layout, beyond the stated display rules.
  • Current law: The supplied materials do not include the Ontario Energy Board Act, 1998, so I could not verify how existing invoice rules compare with this change.

Money#

No cost estimate is available in the supplied material.

  • Distributors would have to meet the new invoice-disclosure duty, but the bill gives no estimate of their costs.
  • No public spending, fee, fine, tax change or funding amount is specified.
  • The disclosure requirement does not itself make consumers pay a new charge.

What is unclear#

  • “Reasonably attributable” is not defined, and the bill does not explain how distributors should calculate the separate amount.
  • No publicly available information on what regulations might require, or when different invoice formats or rules would apply.
  • The bill does not say how consumers could question or challenge the calculation.
  • The supplied material does not show how this duty would interact with current Ontario Energy Board invoice rules.

Case for#

  • A separate, prominent figure could help consumers see the costs connected to gas distribution and cap-and-trade obligations.
  • Including labour, expenses and allowance-related costs could make the disclosure cover more than direct purchases of emission allowances.
  • A regulation-making power could allow invoice requirements to vary where needed.

Case against#

  • The bill does not set a calculation method for “reasonably attributable” costs, so the amount shown may be hard for consumers to assess or compare.
  • Distributors would have to meet a new disclosure duty, but its administrative cost is unknown.
  • The bill says invoice errors or omissions do not invalidate a proceeding to recover the amount payable. That limits the effect an invoice defect alone could have on recovery.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 2017092101

    Passed33 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 146

    FOR · 17AGAINST · 16

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    17For

    • PC10
    • NDP6
    • Independent1

    16Against

    • Liberal16