Summary#
Bill 190, the What You See is What You Pay Act (Consumer Protection Amendment), 2017, would amend Ontario’s Consumer Protection Act, 2002. Its stated goal is to require suppliers to disclose the full cost of goods and services to consumers.
- Suppliers offering, displaying or advertising goods or services in a consumer transaction would have to include the all-inclusive cost in any cost information they give consumers. That cost includes the price, HST and other charges or fees.
- If a supplier shows the all-inclusive cost alongside a separate price, the all-inclusive cost must be shown in a font at least as large as the price.
- For a promotional discount, suppliers would have to clearly state how long it lasts, in a font at least half the size used for the price and all-inclusive cost.
- The Minister could make regulations exempting suppliers, goods or services, or classes of them.
- The Director could issue a notice of contravention. A supplier would have 30 days to meet its requirements; if it did not, and was convicted of an offence, it could face a fine. The amount would depend partly on the supplier’s size and the all-inclusive cost of the highest-priced non-compliant good or service.
- The Act would come into force one year after Royal Assent.
What it means for you#
- Consumers: Cost information would have to include the total amount payable, including HST and other charges or fees. For a promotional discount, its duration would have to be clearly communicated.
- Suppliers: Businesses and other suppliers covered by the rule would have to change how they present cost and promotional information. The bill does not set up a process for consumers to apply for a review or claim compensation.
- Suppliers facing a fine: They could ask the Tribunal in writing to review the facts or fine within 30 days of receiving the fine notice. Payment would be paused until the Tribunal decides. It could confirm the fine, set it aside, or reduce it.
- Consumers generally: The bill would not change tax rates or require suppliers to lower prices. Its stated rules concern disclosure.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- Supplier compliance costs and any government costs for enforcement are not estimated.
- After a supplier fails to meet a notice within 30 days and is convicted, the fine would be up to a fixed amount—$150, $1,500, $10,000 or $25,000, depending on the supplier’s size—plus 100% of the all-inclusive cost of the highest-priced non-compliant good or service.
- The Director and Tribunal would have to consider factors including business size, ability to pay, deterrence, how misleading the price was, prior similar offences and the value of the good or service.
What is unclear#
- The supplied material does not include the current Consumer Protection Act, 2002, so it is not possible to verify how the bill’s rules would interact with existing law.
- The Minister could create exemptions, but the bill does not say which suppliers or goods and services might be exempt.
- The bill does not explain how the rules would apply across different ways of giving price information, or define “promotional discount.”
- The supplied material does not say whether the bill became law.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that showing the total cost, including tax and other fees, could make prices clearer to consumers.
- Requiring the total to appear at least as prominently as a separate price could make it harder to give consumers a misleading impression of what they will pay.
- Requiring suppliers to state how long a promotional discount lasts could help consumers understand the limits of the advertised price.
Case against#
- One concern is that the bill’s broad rule for any cost information could be difficult to apply in some settings; it does not give examples or detailed rules.
- The bill allows exemptions but does not set out limits on them in the text.
- A possible trade-off is that fines tied to the highest-priced non-compliant good or service could be substantial. The bill does require decision-makers to consider factors such as the supplier’s ability to pay and the value of the item, and it allows a Tribunal review.