Bill would require cost disclosures for bills

Summary#

Bill 138, the Transparency in Government Bills Act, 2017, would create a new law. It would require information to be tabled when a government bill is introduced and posted on the Legislative Assembly’s website; its stated goal is to make information about proposed bills available.

  • The required information would include the bill’s problem and policy goals, plus a detailed summary of its financial costs to the government, municipalities, the public, and affected industries or businesses.
  • If a bill would limit competition, the information must explain how its policy goals justify that limit.
  • The information must assess the bill’s relationship to other Ontario laws and describe potential overlap with municipal by-laws or federal laws.
  • If applicable, it must describe effects on Ontario’s global competitiveness and provide a science-based assessment of effects on the environment or human health.
  • The information must be tabled in the Assembly when the government bill is introduced and posted on the Assembly website as soon as possible after introduction.
  • The Act would start on Royal Assent. It does not set out a penalty or require the information to change the bill.

What it means for you#

  • General public: You would be able to access the required information on the Assembly website. The Act does not itself change the rights, fees, or services set by other bills.
  • Municipalities and affected businesses or industries: The required information must include a detailed summary of a government bill’s financial costs to them. This is a disclosure requirement, not a right to compensation or a way to block a bill.
  • Government and the Assembly: Information about each government bill would have to be tabled and posted. The bill does not say who must prepare or verify it.

Money#

No cost information is available for administering this Act.

  • The bill would require government bills to include detailed cost information for the government, municipalities, the public, and affected industries or businesses.
  • It does not specify staffing or other resources for preparing and posting that information.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “government bill” or say who decides whether a bill would affect competition, competitiveness, the environment, or human health.
  • It does not set a standard for what counts as a “detailed” cost summary or a “science-based” assessment.
  • It does not identify who prepares or checks the information, or set a firm deadline beyond “as soon as possible” for posting.
  • It does not state what happens if required information is missing or incomplete, or require the government to respond to the information or change a bill because of it.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to help legislators and the public understand a government bill’s goals, costs, and possible overlap with other laws before it proceeds.
  • Requiring cost information for municipalities, the public, and affected businesses could make costs more visible, not just costs to government.
  • Requiring explanations for competition limits and, where applicable, assessments of environmental or human-health effects could draw attention to impacts that may otherwise be less clear.

Case against#

  • The bill does not set standards for the quality or detail of the information, or require an independent check. The information’s usefulness could therefore vary.
  • It requires disclosure but does not require the government to address identified costs, overlaps, or impacts.
  • The bill does not specify consequences for missing or incomplete information, leaving unclear how the requirement would be enforced.