Electoral district realignment bill

Summary#

Bill 152, the Representation Statute Law Amendment Act, 2017, amends four Ontario laws; it does not create a separate new law or agency. It changes northern electoral districts and election-finance rules. Its stated purpose is to make election-related changes; the supplied material does not give a more specific goal.

  • It replaces two northern districts, Kenora-Rainy River and Timmins-James Bay, with four: Kenora-Rainy River, Kiiwetinoong, Mushkegowuk-James Bay and Timmins. The total number of northern districts rises from 11 to 13.
  • The Attorney General must review the name Mushkegowuk-James Bay in consultation with affected communities and report any recommendations to the Legislature. The Chief Electoral Officer must publicly advertise the four districts in those districts within three months of Royal Assent.
  • Political parties must notify the Chief Electoral Officer when they appoint candidates. The bill also extends nomination contest periods by three months and changes rules for certain fundraising events.
  • The Chief Electoral Officer must register constituency associations for the four districts if they meet application rules and have party approval. Most associations for the old Kenora-Rainy River and Timmins-James Bay districts must dissolve by December 31, 2017, unless a party files to continue one for a specified new district.
  • The Chief Electoral Officer may provide voter-register information to Ontario municipalities, their local boards and the Municipal Property Assessment Corporation for electoral purposes. The Legislative Assembly’s Board of Internal Economy may authorize certain expenses for members from specified northern districts.

What it means for you#

  • Northern residents: The districts you live in may change, affecting which electoral district represents you. The bill sets out district boundaries in detail. It does not change the number of MPPs in the Legislature.
  • Political parties and constituency associations: Parties must report appointed candidates. Associations affected by the new districts must transfer assets and liabilities as the law requires, and file financial statements under transition rules.
  • Candidates and nomination contestants: Nomination contest periods last three months longer. Certain people nominated or appointed as official party candidates, but not registered candidates, are added to a group whose attendance at fundraising events is restricted under existing rules. The supplied text does not set out the full scope of that restriction.
  • People attending party meetings: The bill allows people covered by the fundraising-event rules to attend certain annual general meetings, policy conferences and similar member meetings where the attendance charge includes a contribution portion, if specified advertising and money-handling requirements are met. Contributions at those meetings are excluded when calculating the person’s contribution total under the relevant limits.
  • Municipalities and MPAC: They may receive voter-register information from the Chief Electoral Officer for electoral purposes; the bill does not require the officer to provide it.

Bill 152 received Royal Assent in 2017 and is now enacted as Chapter 18 of the Statutes of Ontario, 2017. The supplied material does not include the parent Acts, so I could not verify the full current-law context beyond the changes described here.

Money#

No cost estimate is available in the supplied material.

  • The bill requires public advertising and a name review, but gives no cost estimate or staffing details.
  • It raises the permitted campaign-expense amount for candidates in specified northern districts, but the supplied text gives no dollar amounts.
  • The Board of Internal Economy may authorize certain expenses for members from named northern districts. The bill does not state the amounts.
  • It allows voter-register information to be shared with additional recipients for electoral purposes; no cost or fee is specified.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not give the campaign-expense increase amounts or estimate the cost of the new duties.
  • The bill gives no deadline for the Attorney General’s name review or report, and does not set out how affected communities are to be consulted.
  • It does not explain how the fundraising rules apply in practice when a member meeting’s charge includes a contribution portion.
  • The bill says voter-register information may be shared for electoral purposes but does not specify what information will be shared or how.
  • The parent Acts were not supplied, so the full existing rules these amendments change could not be checked.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for creating more northern districts is that district boundaries can better reflect the different areas they cover and give residents a more local representative.
  • Requiring consultation on the Mushkegowuk-James Bay name gives affected communities a role in considering that name.
  • Extending nomination contest periods may give contestants and parties more time under the election-finance rules.
  • Allowing certain member meetings with a contribution portion may let parties hold those meetings while keeping contributions subject to specified rules.

Case against#

  • More districts and new constituency associations bring administrative work, but the bill gives no cost estimate or staffing plan.
  • The bill raises campaign-expense limits in specified northern districts without stating the amounts in the supplied text, making the practical effect hard to assess.
  • The name review requires consultation but does not set a deadline or explain how community input will shape recommendations.
  • The Chief Electoral Officer may share voter-register information with additional recipients, but the bill does not detail the information or safeguards in the supplied material.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 2017102401

    Passed87 members voted

    Third Reading of Bill 152

    FOR · 87

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    87For

    • Liberal49
    • PC24
    • NDP13
    • Independent1

    0Against