Municipal Representation and Restructuring Protection Act

Summary#

Bill 121, the Municipal Representation and Restructuring Protection Act, 2019, would create a new Ontario Act; it does not amend another Act directly. Its stated goal is a relationship between the Province and municipalities based on mutual respect, consultation and co-operation.

  • A member of the Executive Council could not include a bill provision making or authorizing certain municipal changes unless the Province gave public notice, consulted the public in affected municipalities, and each affected municipal council approved the change by by-law.
  • Those changes include changing council composition, ward boundaries, municipal boundaries through annexation, amalgamation, separation from or joining an upper-tier municipality, and dissolving all or part of a municipality.
  • A regulation could not change council composition or ward boundaries, or authorize someone other than the municipal council to make those changes, unless the same notice, consultation and council-approval conditions were met.
  • The Lieutenant Governor in Council could make regulations setting rules for notice, consultation and council approval. The Act would start on Royal Assent.

What it means for you#

  • Municipal councils: For a change covered by the bill, the council of each affected municipality would have to approve it by by-law. A council could require that by-law to receive the assent of its electors (approval by voters).
  • Residents of affected municipalities: The Province would have to give public notice and consult the public before making a covered change through a bill or regulation. The bill does not give residents a direct veto; council approval is required, and voter approval would be required only if a council chose to require it.
  • The provincial government: A member of the Executive Council would have to meet the conditions before including a covered change in a bill. The regulation restriction applies to changes to council composition and ward boundaries, not to every type of restructuring listed for bills.
  • Individuals and businesses: The bill does not directly change individual rights, taxes, fees, or services.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill gives the Lieutenant Governor in Council power to set rules by regulation, but provides no spending amount or staffing estimate.
  • It does not specify who would pay for public notice or consultation.

What is unclear#

  • The bill leaves the form and manner of notice and consultation, and who must be consulted, to regulations. It does not set timelines or other detailed process rules.
  • The bill does not define terms such as “consultations” or “public.”
  • The supplied material does not include the full City of Toronto Act, 2006, Municipal Act, 2001, or other potentially relevant laws. I could not verify how the bill’s restrictions would interact with current powers or protections under those laws.
  • It is unclear how the new requirements would interact with existing municipal or provincial processes for the listed changes.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to ensure that major changes to municipal representation or structure involve public notice, consultation and the approval of affected councils.
  • Requiring council approval could give municipalities a formal role before the Province makes or authorizes these changes.
  • Allowing councils to require voter assent could give electors a direct say where a council chooses that route.

Case against#

  • The bill does not set the details of notice or consultation itself, so the practical level of public involvement would depend on regulations.
  • The approval requirement could make some provincial changes dependent on agreement from every affected council; the bill does not explain how disagreements would be resolved.
  • The regulation restriction covers council composition and ward boundaries, but not all the restructuring changes covered by the bill’s rules for bills. This difference may leave the two routes with different protections.