Local government bill reshapes ward map

Summary#

Bill 5, the Better Local Government Act, 2018, was enacted as Chapter 11 of Ontario’s 2018 statutes. It amended the City of Toronto Act, 2006, the Municipal Act, 2001 and the Municipal Elections Act, 1996; it did not create a separate operating program. Its title presents “better local government” as a goal, but the text does not promise a particular result.

  • Toronto’s wards were set to match the boundaries of Ontario electoral districts within the city, and the city’s council was set at the mayor plus one councillor for each ward.
  • Toronto’s 2018 election had to be run as if those ward and council changes were already in force. A bylaw previously passed to change the wards or council composition was deemed not to have been passed.
  • For the 2018 election, the heads of council in Muskoka, Niagara, Peel and York were to be appointed by their regional councillors. The heads of council in Durham, Halton and Waterloo were to be elected by general vote.
  • Toronto council and school-board candidates had to notify the city clerk by 2 p.m. on September 14, 2018, if they wished to remain candidates. Candidates who did not notify the clerk were deemed to have withdrawn.
  • The Minister was given broad powers to make regulations for implementing these changes, including transitional rules. Some such regulations could apply retroactively and prevail over conflicting laws.

What it means for you#

  • Toronto voters: The bill changed the ward map and council composition for the 2018 election. It does not set a new ward map for later elections in the text supplied here.
  • Candidates in Toronto: Council and school-board candidates had to meet the new notice deadline to stay in the 2018 election. The notice did not count as a new nomination. These rules did not apply to candidates for Toronto mayor.
  • Voters and candidates in the named regional municipalities: For the 2018 election, four regional heads of council were selected by regional councillors, while three were elected by general vote. Head-of-council candidates in Muskoka, Niagara, Peel and York were deemed to have withdrawn their nominations.
  • Toronto and regional municipal clerks: Toronto’s clerk had to notify affected candidates about the new notice rules. The bill also allowed the Minister to make regulations about carrying out the election and handling transitions.
  • People in those municipalities: The bill does not directly change taxes, fees, benefits or local services.

Money#

No cost estimate is available in the supplied material.

  • The text gives no spending amount or estimate of election-related costs.
  • Toronto clerks had to send notices, and municipalities had to carry out election changes; this could require staff time, but no staffing or cost figure is given.
  • The text does not create a tax, fee, fine or benefit.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the current consolidated versions of the amended Acts, so later changes and the rules now in force could not be verified.
  • The bill gives the Minister wide regulation-making powers, but the supplied text does not say which regulations were made or what transitional rules were used.
  • The bill does not detail how regional councils were to carry out appointments, or how a municipality could later change its method of selecting its head of council.
  • The text does not provide estimates for municipal election costs or explain how those costs would be shared.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that a single ward map tied to provincial electoral district boundaries could make Toronto’s ward structure clearer and align it with an existing set of boundaries.
  • Setting the council’s composition in law could make the number of councillors follow the number of wards, rather than a separate city decision.
  • Setting out which regional heads would be appointed or elected gave the named municipalities a clear selection method for the 2018 election.

Case against#

  • One concern is that changing Toronto’s wards and council composition for an election already underway could disrupt candidates’ plans and voters’ expectations.
  • The bill gave the Minister power to make retroactive regulations that could prevail over conflicting laws, without setting detailed limits in the text.
  • The new candidate-notice deadline meant some Toronto candidates would be deemed to have withdrawn if they missed it.
  • It is unclear what the changes cost municipalities or how the bill’s election arrangements affected local representation in practice.

Votes

5 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 2018081402

    Passed108 members voted

    Motion for allocation of time on Bill 5, An Act to amend the City of Toronto Act, 2006, the Municipal Act, 2001 and the Municipal Elections Act, 1996.

    FOR · 70AGAINST · 38

    70For

    • PC70

    38Against

    • NDP33
    • Liberal4
    • Green1
  2. Division No. 2018081404

    Passed108 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 5

    FOR · 68AGAINST · 40

    68For

    • PC68

    40Against

    • NDP34
    • Liberal5
    • Green1
  3. Division No. 2018081405

    Passed110 members voted

    Third Reading of Bill 5

    FOR · 71AGAINST · 39

    71For

    • PC71

    39Against

    • NDP33
    • Liberal5
    • Green1
  4. Division No. 2018080201

    Defeated103 members voted

    Ms. Horwath moved, Private Members’ Notice of Motion No. 7: That, in the opinion of this House, the Government of Ontario should not meddle in municipal or regional elections and…

    AGAINST · 68FOR · 35

    68Against

    • PC68

    35For

    • NDP33
    • Green1
    • Liberal1
  5. Division No. 2018073001

    Passed100 members voted

    On motion by Hon. Mr. Clark, Bill 5, An Act to amend the City of Toronto Act, 2006, the Municipal Act, 2001 and the Municipal Elections Act, 1996, was introduced…

    FOR · 60AGAINST · 40

    60For

    • PC60

    40Against

    • NDP34
    • Liberal5
    • Green1