Summary#
Bill 31, the Efficient Local Government Act, 2018, would amend the City of Toronto Act, 2006, the Municipal Act, 2001, the Municipal Elections Act, 1996 and the Education Act. It would undo the legal effect of amendments made by the Better Local Government Act, 2018 and put substantially similar changes back in place, with modifications. The changes are aimed at reorganizing Toronto’s council and changing how some regional council heads are selected; the bill does not guarantee any particular result.
- Toronto’s council after the 2018 election would have the mayor and one councillor for each ward matching an Ontario electoral district within the city. The election would be run as if those boundaries and that council size were already in effect.
- Four regional council heads—Muskoka, Niagara, Peel and York—would be appointed by their councils for the 2018 election. Voters would elect the heads in Durham, Halton and Waterloo by general vote.
- Toronto candidates for council or school board who filed before July 28, 2018, would have to notify the clerk by a new deadline if they wished to remain candidates. Toronto would not have to hold an advance vote, though its clerk could choose to hold one.
- The bill sets out a process for distributing Toronto-area school board seats among geographic areas using population figures. Boards must do the distribution and report it; if a board misses the deadline, the Minister must do it.
- The bill would invoke the Charter’s notwithstanding clause for the amendments, applying them despite sections 2 and 7 to 15 of the Charter and despite Ontario’s Human Rights Code. It would also revoke two election regulations.
What it means for you#
- Toronto voters: You would vote in wards matching provincial electoral districts. The bill would not require the City to offer advance voting.
- Toronto council and school board candidates: If you filed before July 28 and wanted to stay in the race, you would have to notify the clerk in writing by the new deadline. This requirement would not apply to mayoral nominations. A person who did not give the required notice would be treated as having withdrawn.
- Voters in the named regional municipalities: In Muskoka, Niagara, Peel and York, the regional council would appoint its head. In Durham, Halton and Waterloo, voters would elect the head by general vote.
- Toronto-area school boards and election officials: The bill would require population calculations, seat distributions and reports on very short deadlines after Royal Assent.
- General public: The bill changes election rules and government powers; it does not create a new public benefit, tax, fee or front-line service.
Money#
No publicly available information on cost estimates.
- The bill would require the Municipal Property Assessment Corporation, school boards, election clerks and the Minister to do specified work, but gives no staffing or cost estimate.
- No spending amount, tax change, fee or fine is set out in the supplied material.
What is unclear#
- The supplied material does not establish whether the bill became law or its current legal effect.
- The parent Acts are not supplied, so I could not verify the full changes against the law in force or explain the practical effect of all edits to section 218 of the Municipal Act.
- The bill gives the Minister broad regulation-making powers for implementation, including powers to make some regulations retroactive and to have them prevail over conflicting laws. It does not show what regulations would be made.
- The bill does not explain how the fast school-board seat-allocation process would be carried out if the required population data or reports were disputed.
- The supplied material does not provide a cost estimate or say how the required work would be funded.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that matching Toronto wards to provincial electoral districts would set a clear, consistent map for the 2018 election.
- The bill gives a population-based method for distributing school board positions across geographic areas, which could help align representation with the population figures it requires.
- For Durham, Halton and Waterloo, direct election would let voters choose the regional council head; for the other named regions, their councils would make that choice.
Case against#
- One concern is the disruption to an election already underway: candidates would face new deadlines and some nominations would be treated as withdrawn.
- Toronto would not be required to hold an advance vote, so the bill would not guarantee that option for voters.
- The bill lets the Minister make retroactive regulations that can override conflicting laws, while the supplied text does not set out what those regulations would be.
- The bill expressly applies despite specified Charter rights and the Human Rights Code. A possible trade-off is that those protections would not block the covered amendments.