Health accountability bill to boost transparency

Summary#

The official short title is the Strengthening Quality and Accountability for Patients Act, 2017. It amends several existing Ontario laws, creates the Health Sector Payment Transparency Act, 2017 and the Oversight of Health Facilities and Devices Act, 2017, replaces the Medical Radiation Technology Act, 1991, and repeals the Ontario Mental Health Foundation Act. Its stated goal is to strengthen quality and accountability for patients; that is a goal, not a guaranteed result. The Act received Royal Assent in 2017, but some changes were set to start later by proclamation.

  • The Minister of Health gained powers to issue public directives to ambulance services and long-term care homes. Those operators must follow directives that apply to them.
  • The new payment-transparency law requires certain health-sector businesses and others to report prescribed financial transfers to the Minister, who must analyse and publish the information.
  • The new oversight law sets up licensing and enforcement for prescribed community health facilities and certain medical devices. An executive officer runs the system; inspecting bodies may inspect facilities and issue orders. The Minister may provide funding, but the law does not promise it.
  • Long-term care homes and retirement homes face new rules on confining residents. Long-term care homes also face administrative penalties of up to $100,000 for a failure to meet a legal requirement.
  • The Act changes rules for public health, ambulance fees, drug-benefit prescribing, and medical-radiation and imaging professionals, and repeals the law establishing the Ontario Mental Health Foundation.

What it means for you#

  • Patients and the public: The Minister must publish information reported under the payment-transparency law at least once a year. Reporting applies to specified transfers and may include personal information; it is not a requirement to report every financial relationship.
  • People using insured services: The oversight law bars charging patients for access to an insured service at a community health facility, except for facility costs paid by the Minister or another prescribed payer under the law. It does not itself promise public funding for a facility.
  • Long-term care and retirement-home residents: Confinement is subject to conditions, including risk, consideration of alternatives, and consent. In specified cases, residents must receive notice and information about rights-adviser or review processes. The details also depend on regulations.
  • Ambulance operators: They must follow applicable ministerial directives. The Minister may set fees by regulation, but this does not itself impose a new fee on ambulance users.
  • Medical radiation and imaging professionals: The law sets a regulated scope of practice and restricts professional titles to College members. It authorizes listed procedures subject to limits, including required orders for some procedures.
  • Drug-benefit users: Reimbursement criteria may name prescribers or classes of prescribers, not only physicians. This does not itself add drugs to the benefit or guarantee coverage.

Money#

No publicly available information.

  • The Act allows funding for some community health facilities and inspecting bodies, and allows inspecting bodies to charge fees for specified work. No total cost or fee amounts are given.
  • Long-term care homes may face administrative penalties of up to $100,000 per instance of non-compliance, subject to the law’s rules. This is not a forecast of how much would be collected.
  • The payment-transparency law sets criminal fines for violations: up to $10,000 per day for an individual’s first offence and $50,000 per day for a corporation’s first offence, with higher maximums for later offences.

What is unclear#

  • Regulations set important details, including which facilities and devices are covered, safety standards, fees, and reporting thresholds and exemptions.
  • The supplied material does not give the total public cost, staffing needs, facility fees, or expected revenue from penalties.
  • It does not say how much reported payment information, including personal information, the Minister will publish in practice.
  • Some provisions start only on a date set by proclamation. The supplied material does not establish when every provision took effect.
  • The supplied material does not include full, consolidated parent Acts or later amendments, so it does not allow verification of how the law stands today.

Case for#

  • The Act appears intended to make financial ties in health care more visible, giving patients information and government data for planning and research.
  • A licensing and inspection system could set common safety and quality requirements for covered facilities and devices.
  • Confinement rules could protect residents by requiring a serious risk, consideration of less restrictive options, and consent.
  • Ministerial directives could let the government address operational or policy issues across ambulance services and long-term care homes.

Case against#

  • The new oversight system gives officials broad discretion over licences and facility operations, including decisions based on health-system needs and public costs. The materials do not spell out every decision process.
  • Reporting and publication may expose personal information; the law allows some personal information to be included, while leaving important details to regulations and ministerial choices.
  • Facility operators may face new fees and compliance costs, but no estimates are provided.
  • Confinement rules rely in part on regulations and definitions not included here, making it hard to judge how safeguards will work in practice.

Votes

3 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 2017121202

    Passed91 members voted

    Third Reading of Bill 160

    FOR · 49AGAINST · 42

    49For

    • Liberal49

    42Against

    • PC26
    • NDP15
    • Independent1
  2. Division No. 2017102601

    Passed82 members voted

    Motion for closure on Second Reading of Bill 160

    FOR · 49AGAINST · 33

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    49For

    • Liberal49

    33Against

    • PC20
    • NDP13
  3. Division No. 2017102602

    Passed82 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 160

    FOR · 69AGAINST · 13

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    69For

    • Liberal49
    • PC20

    13Against

    • NDP13