Summary#
Bill 8, the Transparent and Accountable Health Care Act, 2018, would create a new Ontario law. It would bring certain health organizations and their suppliers under existing accountability and disclosure laws; its stated goal is to promote transparency and accountability in health-care funding.
- A health organization receiving at least $1 million in public funds from the Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care in a fiscal year would be covered.
- A supplier receiving at least $1 million, directly or indirectly, from covered organizations or other covered suppliers would also be covered. The bill counts payments for goods or services, fee-for-service payments, grants, transfer payments, other funding arrangements, loans and loan guarantees.
- Covered organizations and suppliers would be treated as employers under the compensation-arrangements part of the Broader Public Sector Accountability Act, 2010 and the Public Sector Salary Disclosure Act, 1996, where they are not already employers under those laws.
- They would be treated as governmental organizations under the Ombudsman Act, where they are not already covered. The Auditor General may audit any aspect of their operations.
- The bill lists examples of major health sector organizations, including hospitals and long-term care homes. It would replace “independent health facilities” with “community health facilities” in that list of examples.
What it means for you#
- Health organizations and suppliers: If you meet the $1-million threshold, the bill would subject you to the named laws for the relevant fiscal years. The threshold for suppliers can include funding received indirectly through other suppliers.
- Businesses: For-profit organizations are not excluded. A business could be covered if it meets the applicable threshold.
- People using health services: The bill does not directly change health-care eligibility, services, or patient benefits. It does not create a new health-service program.
- The Auditor General: The office may audit covered organizations and suppliers; the bill does not require an audit of each one.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The bill sets no tax, fee, fine, or spending amount.
- It would require covered organizations and suppliers to meet existing disclosure and accountability requirements. The cost of doing so, and the cost of any audits, is not stated.
What is unclear#
- The Broader Public Sector Accountability Act, 2010, Ombudsman Act, and Public Sector Salary Disclosure Act, 1996 are not supplied, so their existing rules and the exact duties this bill would extend could not be verified.
- The bill does not set out a process for identifying covered organizations or suppliers, or explain what records or reports they must provide.
- It does not say how the $1-million threshold will be checked or how organizations should handle years when their funding rises above or falls below it.
- The bill allows regulations, but no regulations are included.
- The Act would generally start on Royal Assent, but the change to the list of examples has a separate start condition. No date for that condition is provided.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to make public funding more accountable when it flows through health organizations to outside suppliers.
- Applying existing disclosure and oversight laws to organizations and suppliers above a stated funding threshold could extend accountability beyond organizations already covered.
- Giving the Auditor General authority to audit any aspect of a covered organization’s operations could allow examination of more than its public funding alone.
Case against#
- The bill extends several laws without stating their detailed requirements here, making the practical burden hard to assess from this text alone.
- The supplier rule reaches funding received indirectly and through loans or loan guarantees. The bill does not explain how those amounts will be tracked across chains of suppliers.
- The Auditor General may audit any aspect of a covered organization’s operations, but the bill does not set out an audit-selection process or limits beyond the funding threshold.
- The bill does not specify compliance costs, staffing needs, or how the new duties would be funded.