Summary#
Bill 35, the Human Rights Code Amendment Act, 2018, would amend Ontario’s Human Rights Code. It would add immigration status, genetic characteristics, police records and social condition as grounds for equal-treatment protections in several areas. Its stated goal is to extend protection against discrimination to these grounds.
- People would have equal-treatment rights on these grounds in services, goods and facilities; housing; contracts; employment; and membership in certain organizations.
- Employees would also have protection from workplace harassment on these grounds.
- “Police records” would include charges and convictions, even with a record suspension, and other police records, including contact with police. The bill would replace the Code’s defined ground “record of offences” with “police records” in specified provisions.
- “Social condition” would cover social or economic disadvantage linked to employment, income, housing, education, or a similar circumstance. “Immigration status” would mean status under Canadian immigration law.
- Equal treatment based on genetic characteristics would expressly include the right not to undergo a genetic test or disclose its results.
- The bill would also amend other Code provisions, including provisions on immigration status and police records. It would take effect on Royal Assent; it would not create a new agency or program.
What it means for you#
- People seeking or using services, housing, jobs, contracts, or organizational membership: If the bill became law, the Code’s equal-treatment protections would cover discrimination on the four added grounds in those areas. This would not guarantee access or prohibit every distinction; the Code’s exceptions and limits would still matter.
- People with police records: The proposed ground would cover more than convictions, including charges and police contact. The bill does not set out a process for deciding individual cases.
- People asked to take or disclose a genetic test: The proposed protection expressly includes refusing a test or refusing to disclose or authorize disclosure of its results. It does not ban genetic testing.
- Employers and other organizations covered by the Code: They would have to meet the Code’s equal-treatment and applicable harassment requirements with respect to the new grounds.
- Everyone else: The bill would not itself provide a benefit, change immigration status, or create a new front-line service.
Money#
No publicly available information on the bill’s costs is included in the supplied material.
- The bill would extend legal requirements to employers and other organizations, but it gives no estimate of compliance or administration costs.
- It proposes no appropriation, fee, fine, or new benefit.
What is unclear#
- The Human Rights Code itself was not supplied, so the existing rules and the exact effect of the bill’s changes to other provisions and exceptions could not be checked against current law.
- The bill does not explain how complaints would be handled, what evidence or process would apply, or how the new grounds would interact with existing Code protections.
- “Genetic characteristics” is not defined in the supplied bill text. The bill also includes “any other circumstance similar” to the listed causes of social or economic disadvantage without specifying how similarity would be judged.
- No implementation costs or staffing needs are given.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to protect people from unequal treatment based on circumstances that can affect access to work, housing, services, and other areas.
- Explicitly including police contact and charges could address unequal treatment that is not limited to convictions.
- Naming refusal to take or disclose a genetic test could make that protection clearer for people facing such requests.
- Including employment, income, housing and education in the definition of social condition could address disadvantage tied to those circumstances.
Case against#
- The new grounds could reach a wide range of decisions by employers, service providers and other organizations; the bill does not explain how difficult cases would be assessed.
- “Genetic characteristics” and the definition’s reference to similar circumstances are not fully defined in the bill, which may leave uncertainty about the protection’s boundaries.
- Extending the police-records ground to charges and police contact may raise difficult questions about when a distinction is allowed. The bill does not provide a decision process or explain the operation of related exceptions.
- The bill gives no cost estimate, and its changes to existing Code provisions could affect how broadly the new protections apply.