Summary#
Bill 40, the Human Rights Code Amendment Act (Genetic Characteristics), 2018, would amend Ontario’s Human Rights Code; it would not create a separate law or program. Its stated purpose is to add genetic characteristics as a ground of protection against discrimination in several areas, with an exception for some insurance contracts. The supplied materials do not include the current Code, so I could not verify how these changes would interact with its existing provisions.
- The bill would add genetic characteristics to protections for services and facilities, housing, contracts, employment, and membership in certain organizations.
- It defines genetic characteristics as a person’s genetic traits, including traits that may cause or increase the risk of a disorder or disease.
- The protection would include discrimination because a person refuses to take a genetic test or refuses to disclose, or allow disclosure of, its results.
- Insurers could still make distinctions based on genetic characteristics in specified insurance contracts or life annuities, if the grounds are “reasonable and bona fide” (genuine and reasonable).
- The bill also adds genetic characteristics to an existing exception in section 24(1)(a) of the Code. The supplied materials do not include that provision, so its effect cannot be verified here.
What it means for you#
- Individuals: If enacted, you would have a Code-based right to equal treatment in the listed areas without discrimination because of genetic characteristics, including because you refused a genetic test or refused to share its results. The bill does not itself ban asking you to take a test or provide results.
- Workers and job applicants: Genetic characteristics would be added to the Code’s employment protections.
- Housing providers, service providers and organizations: The bill would add genetic characteristics to the listed protections for housing, services and facilities, and membership in certain organizations.
- Insurers: The specified insurance contracts and life annuities could still distinguish based on genetic characteristics where the grounds are reasonable and bona fide.
- Everyone: The bill does not set out application steps, decision timelines or a new complaint process. It would take effect on Royal Assent if enacted.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The bill does not set out public spending, fees, fines or a cost estimate.
- No staffing or other implementation costs are specified.
What is unclear#
- The supplied material does not show the bill’s passage status, so it does not establish whether it became law.
- The current Human Rights Code was not supplied. The effect of the section 24(1)(a) change, and how the changes would fit with existing exceptions, could not be checked.
- The bill does not define what counts as “reasonable and bona fide” grounds for an insurer’s distinction.
- The bill does not set out how the new protections would be applied in individual cases or how they would interact with other existing rules.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that genetic traits, including disease risks, should not by themselves lead to unequal treatment in important areas such as work, housing and services.
- Protecting refusal to take a test or share results could help prevent people from being treated differently because they chose to keep that information private.
- Adding the ground to the Code would give it legal recognition across several areas, rather than limiting the change to one kind of relationship.
Case against#
- One concern is that the insurance exception leaves room for people to face different terms because of genetic characteristics. The bill does not explain how decision-makers would judge whether an insurer’s grounds are reasonable and bona fide.
- The bill extends an existing exception in section 24(1)(a), but the supplied materials do not show what that exception permits. Its effect is therefore unclear here.
- The bill adds protections but does not explain how they would apply to particular cases or how they would interact with existing Code provisions.