Fairness in Consumer Reporting Act

Summary#

Bill 167, the Fairness in Consumer Reporting Act, 2017, would amend Ontario’s Consumer Reporting Act; it would not create a separate consumer-reporting system. Its stated goal, as indicated by its title, is fairness in consumer reporting.

  • Consumer reporting agencies would have to reply to a consumer inquiry within two business days.
  • If a consumer asks, an agency would have to provide a free copy of the consumer’s report in the requested form within two business days, unless the consumer already received five free copies from that agency in the previous 12 months.
  • At a consumer’s request, an agency would have to place or remove a security-freeze notice within two business days. While a notice is in effect, the agency could not disclose information from the file without the consumer’s express consent, except to government agencies named in regulations.
  • Agencies could charge fees for security-freeze placements or removals after the first two in a 12-month period. Regulations could set or limit those fees.
  • The bill would change the deadline for responding to a consumer’s concern to 15 business days and add all other Ontario consumer reporting agencies to a list in that process. The exact effect of that addition is unclear without the full current Act.

What it means for you#

  • Consumers: You could request a free report up to five times from the same agency in a 12-month period. The bill would not require further copies to be free.
  • Consumers: You could ask an agency to freeze your file and later remove the freeze. The bill does not explain how long a freeze lasts or what steps, beyond following regulations and providing required information, a request involves.
  • People or businesses seeking information from a frozen file: The agency generally could not disclose file information without the consumer’s express consent. The exception would be for government agencies named in regulations.
  • Consumer reporting agencies: They would have to meet the new response deadlines and handle freeze requests. The bill does not set out a full process for inquiries or complaints.
  • Current law: The supplied material does not include the current Consumer Reporting Act, so I could not verify which protections, duties or procedures already exist.

Money#

No publicly available information on estimated public or private costs.

  • Agencies would have to provide staff and other resources to meet the new deadlines, but no staffing requirement or cost estimate is given.
  • Consumers would not be charged for the first two security-freeze placements or removals in a 12-month period. The bill allows fees for later ones, subject to regulations.
  • The bill does not state what a later fee would be or whether regulations would restrict it.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “inquiry” or set out what counts as a reply.
  • Regulations would set how consumers request or remove a freeze, what information they must provide, which government agencies may receive information from frozen files, and how freeze fees work. Those rules are not included.
  • The bill does not say how long a freeze lasts or how an agency determines that a notice has expired.
  • It changes part of the existing consumer-concern process, but the full section is not supplied. The exact duty created by adding all other Ontario agencies to its list cannot be verified.
  • The bill changes wording in another part of the Act to say “on and after January 1, 2021,” but the supplied text does not include enough of that section to explain the practical effect.
  • The bill would start on a date set by proclamation. No start date is provided.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that consumers should be able to get timely answers and copies of their reports without paying each time, up to the stated limit.
  • A security freeze could give consumers more control over disclosure of their file, while allowing exceptions set for government agencies.
  • Clear deadlines could make agencies’ response obligations more predictable than the existing “reasonable time” wording cited in the bill.

Case against#

  • One concern is that a freeze would restrict disclosure to anyone unless the consumer gives express consent, with only a regulation-based government exception. That could complicate situations where another person or business needs information from the file.
  • The bill leaves important details—including freeze duration, request procedures and possible fees—to later regulations.
  • Agencies would face new deadlines, but the bill gives no cost estimate or detail on what happens if an agency misses a deadline.
  • Because the current Act is not included, it is unclear how the new rules would fit with existing duties and processes.