Summary#
Bill 199, the Access to Consumer Credit Reports and Elevator Availability Act, 2018, would amend Ontario’s Consumer Reporting Act and Technical Standards and Safety Act, 2000. Its stated goal is to change consumer credit disclosures and enable rules about elevator availability and enforcement. The supplied materials do not include the current versions of those Acts, so I could not verify the full current-law baseline.
- Consumer credit: A consumer could request their credit report, or their current consumer score and report. Credit reporting agencies would have to provide specified information, explain score factors on request, and use the score-generation method required by the bill or regulations.
- Consumer control: A consumer could require a prescribed agency to place a security freeze on their file. While it is in effect, the agency generally could not disclose the consumer’s credit or personal information, subject to regulatory exceptions and the consumer’s directions.
- Agency oversight: The Registrar could require records and information, investigate agencies’ practices, and order changes to information or practices to ensure compliance.
- Elevators: The Lieutenant Governor in Council could make regulations setting availability and repair standards, requiring outage reports, and requiring public databases. The bill itself does not set those standards or require a database to be created immediately.
- Penalties: An assessor appointed by the Corporation could impose a penalty of up to $10,000 for specified violations. The person could appeal within 15 days; penalties would be payable to the Corporation.
What it means for you#
- Consumers: You could ask for your report or your score and report, with information such as the score’s date, range and factors, and details about recipients of certain reports or scores. Agencies would have to use understandable language and provide trained staff to explain disclosures. You could bring one other person to an in-person disclosure.
- Consumers: You could request a freeze to limit disclosure of information in your file. You would need to verify your identity. The agency must place or end the freeze by deadlines set in regulations, or otherwise as the bill provides. A freeze would not block disclosures allowed by regulations or ones you direct to a named person or organization.
- Credit reporting agencies: They would have to meet new disclosure, score-generation, freeze, website-publication and Registrar-information requirements. Disclosure fees would generally be barred unless regulations allow them, with limited exceptions after repeated disclosures in a calendar year.
- Elevator users and the public: Regulations could set availability and repair requirements and require public information about elevators or outages. The bill does not itself set how often elevators must work, how quickly they must be repaired, or what information would be public.
- People or businesses responsible for elevators: Regulations could assign responsibility for meeting availability standards and reporting outages. The bill does not itself identify who must report.
- People subject to elevator-safety enforcement: A penalty could be imposed even if the person took reasonable steps to prevent a violation or honestly and reasonably misunderstood the facts. Paying the penalty bars an offence charge, and other prescribed measures, for that same violation. The bill also sets possible offence fines of up to $50,000 for an individual and $1 million for a corporation.
Money#
No cost estimate is available in the supplied material.
- Credit reporting agencies would have to provide trained personnel and meet new disclosure, publication and record-production duties; no staffing or compliance-cost estimate is given.
- Regulations could allow certain consumer fees, but the bill does not set fee amounts.
- Regulations could require elevator outage reporting and public databases; the bill gives no estimate of the costs or who would bear them.
- Penalties would go to the Corporation. Regulations could set how the Corporation may use that money.
What is unclear#
- Many details depend on future regulations, including deadlines, fees, exceptions to freezes, score methods and which agencies are covered.
- The bill does not set elevator availability standards, repair times, reporting rules, who is responsible, or what the public databases must contain.
- It is unclear how the new Registrar powers and freeze rules would interact with existing processes. The supplied materials do not include the parent Acts needed to check that.
- The bill allows a penalty order without a hearing, subject to regulations, and provides an appeal. The regulations would determine important parts of the penalty and appeal process.
- The bill’s consumer-score definition may be further defined by regulation; without that definition, it includes a score, grade or value based on information an agency maintains about a consumer.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the credit-report changes is that consumers would get more information about their scores and who received reports or scores.
- A freeze could give consumers a way to restrict disclosure of their file, while still allowing disclosures they direct and exceptions set by regulation.
- Registrar inquiries and orders could help address inaccurate information or agency practices that break the law.
- Elevator standards, outage reporting and public databases could make availability problems more visible and support clearer safety rules.
- Administrative penalties could encourage compliance and prevent people from keeping an economic benefit from a violation.
Case against#
- Key consumer protections depend on regulations that are not included here, so their practical scope, timing and cost are uncertain.
- A freeze could block disclosure of a consumer’s information broadly; the bill leaves important exceptions to regulations.
- The bill permits penalties without a hearing in some cases and says they can apply despite reasonable prevention steps or an honest factual mistake. An appeal is available, but its detailed rules are not set in the bill.
- The bill enables elevator rules but does not itself guarantee a particular level of availability, repair speed or public reporting.
- New duties for agencies and possible elevator reporting or database systems could cost money, but the materials do not estimate those costs.