Consent rules curb personal data disclosures

Summary#

Bill 55, the Safeguarding our Information Act, 2018, would amend three existing Ontario Acts: the Consumer Protection Act, 2002, the Consumer Reporting Act, and the Credit Unions and Caisses Populaires Act, 1994. It would make a consumer’s or credit union member’s consent a condition for certain disclosures to government institutions. Its stated aim is to limit the disclosure of confidential information.

  • A lender could disclose a consumer’s personal information to an Ontario or federal government institution only if the consumer consents, when the institution requests it under lawful authority.
  • A consumer reporting agency could disclose information about a consumer to such an institution only with the consumer’s consent.
  • A credit union could disclose information about a member to such an institution only with the member’s consent, despite the existing provision referred to in the Act.
  • The bill does not create a new agency, program, or funding source. It does not require lenders or other organizations to disclose information even when they have consent.

What it means for you#

  • Consumers: If a government institution makes a covered request to a lender or consumer reporting agency, that organization could disclose your information only if you consent.
  • Credit union members: A credit union could disclose information about you to a government institution making a covered request only if you consent.
  • Lenders, consumer reporting agencies, and credit unions: They would have to meet the consent condition before making these disclosures.
  • Government institutions: The bill would not remove their ability to make requests under lawful authority, but the organizations receiving those requests could not disclose the covered information without consent.
  • Everyone else: The bill does not directly change taxes, benefits, or access to government services.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill does not set out an appropriation, fee, or fine.
  • It does not estimate staffing or compliance costs for the affected organizations or governments.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not explain how consent must be requested, recorded, or verified.
  • It does not define “lawful authority” or set out exceptions to the consent condition.
  • “Information regarding a consumer” and “information respecting a member” are not defined in the bill.
  • The parent Acts were not supplied, so the current disclosure rules and how these changes fit with them could not be verified. No publicly available information.
  • The text says the Act would start on Royal Assent, but the supplied material does not say whether the bill passed. No publicly available information.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that people should have a say before lenders, consumer reporting agencies, or credit unions disclose information about them to government.
  • The consent condition applies even when a government institution makes a request under lawful authority, so it could provide a clear privacy safeguard in those situations.
  • The bill applies the consent condition across three types of organizations that may hold consumer or member information.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the consent requirement could make it harder for government institutions to obtain information through these organizations, including when they make a request under lawful authority.
  • The bill does not explain what happens if a person cannot be reached or does not respond.
  • It is unclear how the new conditions would interact with other disclosure rules in the amended Acts or with other laws.