Protection Orders for Human Trafficking Victims

Summary#

Bill 17, Saving the Girl Next Door Act, 2016, would create two new Acts and amend Ontario’s Christopher’s Law (Sex Offender Registry), 2000. Its stated goals include raising awareness of human trafficking and protecting people from child sexual exploitation and human trafficking.

  • It would proclaim February 22 each year as Human Trafficking Awareness Day.
  • It would let a judge make a protection order if the judge finds, on a balance of probabilities, that someone exploited or trafficked a person and that the person needs immediate or imminent protection.
  • The judge could order the respondent not to contact or approach the subject, return specified documents or personal effects, and stop sharing images of the subject. Orders usually last three years, but a judge could set a longer period.
  • It would create a civil tort of human trafficking (a basis for suing). A person could sue without proving damage; the defendant could not rely on the plaintiff’s consent as a defence.
  • It would add specified Criminal Code offences involving trafficking and sexual services related to people under 18 to the definition of “sex offence” in Christopher’s Law.
  • The awareness day provision would start on Royal Assent. The other two schedules would start on the first anniversary of Royal Assent.

What it means for you#

  • People seeking protection: An adult subject could apply for an order. For a subject under 18, a parent or guardian, certain children’s aid societies or other authorized people could apply. A judge could make an order without first notifying the respondent.
  • Respondents: An order would bind the respondent once served. They could ask the court to set it aside or change it, but that request would not pause the order. Breaching an order could bring a fine of up to $50,000, up to two years in prison, or both.
  • People bringing a trafficking lawsuit: A court could award damages, order the defendant to account for profits, issue an injunction, or make another just order. The bill says a person may sue without proof of damage and that consent is no defence.
  • People covered by protection-order proceedings, and publishers: The bill restricts publishing identifying information during specified periods, and permanently bars identifying a person in the proceeding who is under 18. Breaking these restrictions could bring an individual a fine of up to $5,000, up to two years in prison, or both. A corporation could face a fine of up to $50,000.
  • People convicted of listed Criminal Code offences: The bill would add those offences to the sex-offence definition in Christopher’s Law. The parent Act was not supplied, so the exact registration consequences cannot be verified here.

Money#

No cost estimate is available in the supplied material.

  • The bill does not specify an appropriation, fees, or funding for the new court process.
  • Court and administration resources may be needed; that is an inference, not a cost stated in the bill.
  • A court could order a trafficking defendant to pay damages or account for profits. These are possible court remedies, not a guaranteed payment.

What is unclear#

  • The bill leaves regulations to set important details, including which courts and judicial officers handle applications and how applications, service, and hearings work.
  • It does not set out detailed rules for notice-free applications, beyond allowing them and requiring supporting evidence under oath.
  • It does not explain how the new Act would interact with existing protections or remedies. The supplied material does not include the current Christopher’s Law, so its existing registration rules and the full effect of the amendment could not be checked.
  • The bill does not define all terms used in the new Act; it allows regulations to define or change the meaning of some terms.
  • The bill’s passage and actual start dates are not stated in the supplied material.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to provide a direct way to seek protection where a judge finds exploitation or trafficking and an urgent or imminent risk.
  • Allowing orders without notice may make it possible to seek protection before alerting the respondent. The respondent would still have a right to ask the court to change or set aside the order.
  • A civil claim without proof of damage, with possible damages and profit accounting, could give a person another way to seek a remedy.
  • A yearly awareness day and a broader sex-offence definition are measures aimed at recognition and response, though the bill does not guarantee particular results.

Case against#

  • A judge could make an order without notice, and the respondent bears the burden of showing it should be changed or set aside. This may limit a respondent’s chance to answer the case before restrictions take effect.
  • The bill leaves much of the application and hearing process to regulations, so key practical safeguards and procedures are not in the bill itself.
  • Publication restrictions and significant penalties may affect reporting and communication about proceedings, even though the bill includes time limits and court powers over identification.
  • The bill does not provide cost estimates or explain how courts would handle the new process.