Protecting Vulnerable Road Users Act

Summary#

Bill 54, the Protecting Vulnerable Road Users Act, 2021, would amend Ontario’s Highway Traffic Act. Its stated goal is to set additional legal consequences when a driver’s breach of specified road rules causes or contributes to a death or serious bodily harm to a vulnerable road user.

  • A covered driver would commit a new offence only if the driver’s breach of a listed rule caused or contributed to the harm. The offence would not be one of absolute liability (the prosecution would still have to prove the offence).
  • The protected people include pedestrians, people on bicycles or motor-assisted bicycles, people using mobility devices, roadway workers, and certain emergency workers outside motor vehicles. Regulations could add other people.
  • A convicted driver would face the penalty and other consequences that apply to the underlying rule violation, plus a mandatory probation order lasting no more than one year.
  • The order must require a driving instruction course and 50 to 200 hours of community service. The service must include public education about driving safety or another activity to improve it. The driver’s licence would be suspended for the order’s duration.
  • The bill also sets rules for charging and sentencing: the defendant must attend sentencing, and the court must consider relevant victim impact statements.

What it means for you#

  • Drivers: If you are convicted of the new offence, you would face the underlying rule’s penalty and consequences, plus the required probation conditions and licence suspension. The bill lists breaches involving, among other things, impaired or unlicensed driving, cellphone use, speeding, careless driving, traffic signals, and sharing the road.
  • Drivers of motor-assisted bicycles: They are not included among the drivers covered by the new offence. But people riding motor-assisted bicycles are included among the protected road users.
  • Protected road users and people affected by a collision: The bill does not create a right to compensation. A person who suffered or claims harm, property damage, or economic loss could give a statement for the court to consider when setting penalties and other consequences.
  • Courts and defendants: Defendants would have to attend sentencing in person. A breach of probation could lead to a fine of up to $50,000; the court may also suspend a licence or permit for up to two years.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s cost.

  • The bill requires a driving course and community service for convicted drivers but gives no cost estimate or information about who would pay for the course.
  • It gives no estimate of added costs for courts, enforcement, or administering probation.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the current Highway Traffic Act, so it is not possible to verify how these rules would compare with current law or what existing consequences would apply to each listed breach.
  • The bill does not explain how the new offence would interact with other charges or processes arising from the same collision.
  • Regulations could add protected groups and set course requirements, but those details are not in the bill text.
  • The supplied material does not show whether the bill became law. If enacted, it would start six months after Royal Assent.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to address collisions where a breach of a listed road rule causes or contributes to death or serious bodily harm.
  • A possible argument for the added probation conditions is that they require both driving instruction and community service tied to road safety, rather than relying only on the underlying penalty.
  • Requiring defendants to attend sentencing and allowing impact statements could give the court direct information about the harm when deciding consequences.

Case against#

  • The mandatory probation order and licence suspension would apply in addition to the underlying penalty, even though the bill does not set different conditions for different levels of harm or circumstances.
  • The bill leaves course requirements and any additional protected groups to regulations, so important details are not settled in the text.
  • The bill does not estimate the cost of courses or added court and enforcement work, or explain how those costs would be covered.