Protects Trafficking Victims From Coerced Debts

Summary#

Bill 99, the Protection from Coerced Debts Incurred in relation to Human Trafficking Act, 2022, would amend Ontario’s Consumer Reporting Act and the Prevention of and Remedies for Human Trafficking Act, 2017. It would also rename the latter Act as the Prevention of, Remedies for and Measures to Support Recovery from Human Trafficking Act, 2017. The bill’s stated goal is to protect people from debts incurred while they were being trafficked and from related harm to their consumer reports or access to services.

  • It would define a “coerced debt” as a debt incurred under a credit facility while the debtor was being subjected to human trafficking.
  • No person or entity, including a creditor, could collect or try to collect a coerced debt.
  • No person or entity could consider the existence of such a debt when deciding whether to provide the debtor with services or products.
  • Consumer reports could not include unfavourable personal information about a consumer that resulted from human trafficking.
  • If a debtor and creditor disagree about whether a debt is coerced, either could apply to a Tribunal. The Minister may make regulations to name the Tribunal and set rules for applications.
  • The bill says it would take effect on Royal Assent. It does not itself set out a start date beyond that.

What it means for you#

  • People subjected to human trafficking: If a debt meets the bill’s definition, it could not be collected, and its existence could not be considered in decisions about services or products. The bill does not expressly cancel the debt.
  • Creditors and other businesses or service providers: They would be barred from collecting a coerced debt or considering it when deciding whether to provide a product or service. The ban would apply despite other Acts.
  • Consumer reporting agencies: They could not include unfavourable personal information about a consumer that resulted from human trafficking.
  • Debtors and creditors in a dispute: Either could apply to the Tribunal, which would decide whether all or part of the debt is coerced and, if so, the amount.
  • General public: The bill does not directly change ordinary debts that do not meet its definition.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill does not set a budget, funding amount, or staffing requirement.
  • Regulations could designate a Tribunal and govern applications, but the bill gives no cost estimate for that work.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “credit facility” or set out how someone would show that a debt was incurred while they were being trafficked.
  • The definition requires the debt to have been incurred during trafficking; it does not expressly require proof that the trafficking caused the debt.
  • The bill leaves Tribunal rules to regulations. It does not set application steps, timelines, appeal rights, or reporting requirements.
  • It does not expressly say that a coerced debt is cancelled or explain how it may be treated outside consumer reports.
  • The parent Acts were not supplied, so the bill’s changes could not be checked against current law or existing protections.

Case for#

  • A person subjected to trafficking may incur debt during that period. Barring collection could protect them from being pursued for it.
  • Keeping related unfavourable information out of consumer reports, and barring its use in decisions about products or services, could reduce further effects of that debt.
  • Letting either the debtor or creditor seek a Tribunal decision provides a route to resolve disagreement about whether a debt, or part of it, qualifies.

Case against#

  • The definition covers debts incurred while a person was being trafficked, without expressly requiring a link between the trafficking and the debt. That could make it hard to know which debts qualify.
  • The bill sets broad prohibitions but leaves important details, including how to apply and how disputes are handled, to later regulations.
  • It bars collection but does not expressly cancel the debt. The bill does not explain what happens to the debt in other contexts, such as records outside consumer reports.