Summary#
The Colleges of Applied Arts and Technology Labour Dispute Resolution Act, 2017 was enacted as a separate, special law to address the 2017 college faculty dispute. It did not amend the Colleges Collective Bargaining Act, 2008, but that Act continues to apply except where this law conflicts with it. The stated goal was to end the work stoppage and reach a new collective agreement through mediation-arbitration (a process that combines attempts to settle with a binding decision if needed).
- Once the law received Royal Assent, colleges had to use all reasonable efforts to operate; the College Employer Council had to assist them. The Council and colleges had to end any lock-out, and the union and employees had to end any strike.
- Until a new agreement took effect, strikes and lock-outs were prohibited, subject to the law’s stated exceptions. After a new agreement took effect, the 2008 Act governed those rights.
- The law sent the unresolved terms of the agreement to a mediator-arbitrator. The parties had five days to appoint one jointly; if they did not, the Minister of Labour had to appoint one.
- The mediator-arbitrator could decide all matters considered necessary for the agreement. The decision had to consider listed factors, including employers’ ability to pay and the effect on services, and would bind the parties, colleges and covered employees.
- The law applied only if no new agreement had been executed after September 30, 2017, and before Royal Assent. It covered the full-time academic staff bargaining unit.
What it means for you#
- Faculty and their union: Covered employees had to return to work, subject to an exception for health reasons or mutual consent with the employer. Existing employment terms continued until a new agreement took effect, unless the parties agreed otherwise. The arbitrator could make some terms retroactive to dates after September 30, 2017.
- Colleges and the Council: Colleges had to make reasonable efforts to operate, and the Council had to assist. They could not lock out covered employees while the prohibition applied.
- Students and other college service users: The law required efforts to resume operations, but it did not guarantee a particular reopening date or uninterrupted services.
- People covered by the bargaining unit: A breach of the strike, lock-out or operating duties was an offence. On conviction, an individual could be fined up to $1,000; another person or an employee organization could be fined up to $25,000. Each day of a continuing breach counted as a separate offence.
- General public: This law addressed one specified bargaining dispute; it did not create a general new college service or benefit.
Money#
The parties had to split the mediator-arbitrator’s fees and expenses equally, but no total cost estimate is provided.
- The law gives no estimate of public spending, staffing costs or any effect on college services.
- No cost information is available for colleges’ efforts to resume operations.
What is unclear#
- The supplied material does not say when the Act was repealed. It says repeal would occur on a date set by proclamation.
- The supplied material does not establish whether the Act has since been repealed or provide the current text of the Colleges Collective Bargaining Act, 2008. Current law and the exact interaction between the two Acts cannot be verified here.
- The law set deadlines for appointing the arbitrator and making an award, but allowed the parties and arbitrator to extend some deadlines by written agreement. The final timing is not provided.
- The arbitrator had broad authority to decide matters needed for an agreement and to consider factors the arbitrator considered relevant. The text does not specify how those factors must be weighed.
Case for#
- The law appears intended to end a prolonged work stoppage that had disrupted college education and training, as described in its preamble.
- A binding process offered a way to settle unresolved terms when bargaining had reached an impasse.
- Requiring a joint appointment first, while allowing the Minister to appoint if the parties failed, gave the parties a chance to choose the arbitrator without letting a failure to agree halt the process.
- The listed award factors required attention to employers’ ability to pay, possible service reductions, Ontario’s economy and employees’ ability to be attracted and retained.
Case against#
- The law ended the strike and barred further strikes and lock-outs during the process, removing those forms of bargaining pressure until a new agreement took effect.
- The arbitrator could decide all matters considered necessary and had to consider broad criteria, but the law did not prescribe how competing factors should be balanced.
- A binding outcome could affect employment terms and service levels, while the law’s stated criteria include employers’ finances and the possibility of service reductions.
- The law set deadlines but allowed extensions, and the available material gives no final cost or outcome figures.